To estimate the exact value of the work done by S. Gregory in the
establishment of the doctrine of the Trinity and in the determination,
so far as Eastern Christendom is concerned, of the terminology employed
for the expression of that doctrine, is a task which can hardly be
satisfactorily carried out. His teaching on the subject is so closely
bound up with that of his brother, S. Basil of Cæsarea,—his
“master,” to use his own phrase,—that the two can
hardly be separated with any certainty. Where a disciple, carrying on
the teaching he has himself received from another, with perhaps almost
imperceptible variations of expression, has extended the influence of
that teaching and strengthened its hold on the minds of men, it must
always be a matter of some difficulty to discriminate accurately
between the services which the two have rendered to their common cause,
and to say how far the result attained is due to the earlier, how far
to the later presentment of the doctrine. But the task of so
discriminating between the work of S. Basil and that of S. Gregory is
rendered yet more complicated by the uncertainty attaching to the
authorship of particular treatises which have been claimed for both.
If, for instance, we could with certainty assign to S. Gregory that
treatise on the terms οὐσία and ὑπόστασις, which Dorner treats as one of the works by which he
“contributed materially to fix the uncertain usage of the
Church See
Dorner, Doctrine of the Person of Christ, Div. I. vol. ii. p.
314 (English Trans.).,” but which is found also among the
works of S. Basil in the form of a letter addressed to S. Gregory
himself, we should be able to estimate the nature and the extent of the
influence of the Bishop of Nyssa much more definitely than we can
possibly do while the authorship of this treatise remains uncertain.
Nor does this document stand alone in this respect, although it is
perhaps of more importance for the determination of such a question
than any other of the disputed treatises. Thus in the absence of
certainty as to the precise extent to which S. Gregory’s teaching
was directly indebted to that of his brother, it seems impossible to
say how far the “fixing of the uncertain usage of the
Church” was due to either of them singly. That together they did
contribute very largely to that result is beyond
question: and it is perhaps superfluous to endeavour to separate their
contributions, especially as there can be little doubt that S. Gregory
at least conceived himself to be in agreement with S. Basil upon all
important points, if not to be acting simply as the mouth-piece of his
“master’s” teaching, and as the defender of the
statements which his “master” had set forth against
possible misconceptions of their meaning. Some points, indeed, there
clearly were, in which S. Gregory’s presentment of the doctrine
differs from that of S. Basil; but to these it may be better to revert
at a later stage, after considering the more striking variation which
their teaching displays from the language of the earlier Nicene school
as represented by S. Athanasius.