The story itself is given at second-hand, from
Ammon’s recollection of a statement by Athanasius some 12 to 15
years (at least) before he wrote. The prophetic details about Jovian
may therefore be put down to natural accretion (Letter 56, note
2). But (apart from the fact that Julian’s death must have been
rumoured long before the tardy official announcement of it, Tillem.
Emp. iv. 449 sqq., Prolegg. ubi supr.) that
Athanasius told of the φήμη
of Julian’s death among the monks of the Thebaid need not be
doubted. The story is one of a very large class, many of which are
fairly authenticated. To say nothing of the φήμη at the battle of Mycale; we have
in recent times the authority of Mr. R. Stuart Poole, of the British
Museum, for the fact that on the night of the death of the Duke of
Cambridge (July 9, 1850), Mr. Pooles’s brother ‘suddenly
took out his watch and said, “Note the time, the Duke of
Cambridge is dead,” and that the time proved to be
correct;’ also the case of Mr. Edmonds who saw at Leicester,
early in the morning of Nov. 4, 1837, an irruption of water into the
works of the Thames tunnel, by which a workman was drowned; (other
curious cases in ‘Phantasms of the Living’ vol. 2, pp. 367
sqq.). The letter or memoir from which this
‘Narratio’ is taken, was published by the Bollandists from
a Medicean ms., and it bears every internal
mark of genuineness. In what way it is integrally connected with the
Vita Antonii (Gwatkin, Studies, p. 101), except by the
fact that it happens to mention Antony, I fail to see. On the subject
of Theodore of Tabenne, the main subject of the memoir, see
Amélineau’s S. Pakhôme ( ut supra, p.
188), also infr. Letter 58, note 3.