1. Of all other heresies
which have departed from the truth it is acknowledged that they have
but devised ἐπινοήσασαι. This is almost a technical word, and has occurred again
and again already, as descriptive of heretical teaching in opposition
to the received traditionary doctrine. It is also found passim
in other writers. Thus Socrates, speaking of the decree of the Council
of Alexandria, 362, against Apollinaris; ‘for not
originating, ἐπινοήσαντες, any novel devotion, did they introduce it into the
Church, but what from the beginning the Ecclesiastical Tradition
declared.’ Hist. iii. 7. The sense of the word
ἐπίνοια which will come into consideration below, is akin to this, being
the view taken by the mind of an object independent of (whether or not
correspondent to) the object itself. [But see Bigg. B. L. p.
168, sq.] a madness, and their irreligiousness
has long since become notorious to all men. For that τὸ γὰρ
ἐξελθεῖν…δῆλον ἂν
εἴη, i.e. τῷ and so infr.
§43. τὸ δὲ
καὶ
προσκυνεῖσθαι…δῆλον ἂν
εἴη. their authors went out from us, it plainly
follows, as the blessed John has written, that they never thought nor
now think with us. Wherefore, as saith the Saviour, in that they gather
not with us, they scatter with the devil, and keep an eye on those who
slumber, that, by this second sowing of their own mortal poison, they
may have companions in death. But, whereas one heresy, and that the
last, which has now risen as harbinger de
Syn. 5. of
Antichrist, the Arian, as it is called, considering that other
heresies, her elder sisters, have been openly proscribed, in her craft
and cunning, affects to array herself in Scripture language Vid.
infr. §4 fin. That heresies before the Arian appealed to Scripture
we learn from Tertullian, de Præscr. 42, who warns
Catholics against indulging themselves in their own view of isolated
texts against the voice of the Catholic Church. vid. also Vincentius,
who specifies obiter Sabellius and Novation. Commonit. 2.
Still Arianism was contrasted with other heresies on this point, as in
these two respects; (1.) they appealed to a secret tradition,
unknown even to most of the Apostles, as the Gnostics, Iren.
Hær. iii. 1 or they professed a gift of prophecy
introducing fresh revelations, as Montanists, de Syn. 4,
and Manichees, Aug. contr. Faust. xxxii. 6. (2.) The Arians
availed themselves of certain texts as objections, argued keenly and
plausibly from them, and would not be driven from them. Orat.
ii. §18. c. Epiph. Hær. 69. 15. Or rather they took
some words of Scripture, and made their own deductions from them; viz.
‘Son,’ ‘made,’ ‘exalted,’ &c.
‘Making their private irreligiousness as if a rule, they
misinterpret all the divine oracles by it.’ Orat. i.
§52. vid. also Epiph. Hær. 76. 5 fin. Hence we hear so
much of their θρυλληταὶ
φωναὶ, λέξεις,
ἔπη, ῥητὰ, sayings in general circulation, which were commonly founded on
some particular text. e.g. infr., §22, ‘amply providing
themselves with words of craft, they used to go about,’ &c.
Also ἄνω καὶ κάτω
περιφέροντες, de Decr. §13. τῷ ῥ& 208·τῳ
τεθρυλλήκασι
τὰ
πανταχοῦ. Orat. 2. §18. τὸ
πολυθρύλλητον
σόφισμα,
Basil. contr. Eunom. ii. 14. τὴν
πολυθρύλλητον
διαλεκτικήν, Nyssen. contr. Eun. iii. p. 125. τὴν
θρυλλουμένην
ἀποῤ&
191·οήν, Cyril.
Dial. iv. p. 505. τὴν
πολυθρύλλητον
φώνην, Socr. ii.
43., like her father the devil, and is forcing
her way back into the Church’s paradise,—that with the
pretence of Christianity, her smooth sophistry (for reason she has
none) may deceive men into wrong thoughts of Christ,—nay, since
she has already seduced certain of the foolish, not only to corrupt
their ears, but even to take and eat with Eve, till in their ignorance
which ensues they think bitter sweet, and admire this loathsome heresy,
on this account I have thought it necessary, at your request, to unrip
‘the folds of its breast-plate Job xli. 13 (v. 4.
LXX).,’ and to
shew the ill savour of its folly. So while those who are far from it
may continue to shun it, those whom it has deceived may repent; and,
opening the eyes of their heart, may understand that darkness is not
light, nor falsehood truth, nor Arianism good; nay, that those These
Orations and Discourses seem written to shew the vital importance of
the point in controversy, and the unchristian character of the heresy,
without reference to the word ὁμοούσιον. He has [elsewhere] insisted that the enforcement of the
symbol was but the rejection of the heresy, and accordingly he is here
content to bring out the Catholic sense, as feeling that, if persons
understood and embraced it, they would not scruple at the word. He
seems to allude to what may be called the liberal or indifferent
feeling as swaying the person for whom he writes, also infr. §7
fin. §9. §10 init. §15 fin. §17. §21.
§23. He mentions in Apollin. i. 6. one Rhetorius, who was
an Egyptian, whose opinion, he says, it was ‘fearful to
mention.’ S. Augustine tells us that this man taught that
‘all heresies were in the right path, and spoke truth,’
‘which,’ he adds, ‘is so absurd as to seem to me
incredible.’ Hær 72. vid. also Philastr.
Hær. 91. who call these men Christians are in great
and grievous error, as neither having studied Scripture, nor
understanding Christianity at all, and the faith which it contains.