The letter against John of Jerusalem was written about
the year 398 or 399, and was a product of the Origenistic controversy.
Its immediate occasion was the visit of Epiphanius, bishop of Salamis
in Cyprus, at Jerusalem, in 394. The bishop preached, in the Church of
the Resurrection (§11), a pointed sermon against Origenism, which
was thought to be so directly aimed at John that the latter sent his
archdeacon to remonstrate with the preacher (§14). After many
unseemly scenes, Epiphanius advised Jerome and his friends to separate
from their bishop (§39). But how were they to have the
ministrations of the Church? This difficulty was surmounted by
Epiphanius, who took Jerome’s brother to the monastery which he
had founded at Ad, in the diocese of Eleutheropolis, and there ordained
him against his will, even using force to overcome his opposition
(Jerome, Letter LI. 1). Epiphanius attempted to defend his action
(Jerome, Letter LI. 2), but John, after some time, appealed to
Alexandria against Jerome and his supporters as schismatics. The
bishop, Theophilus, at once took the side of John: but a letter,
written by his emissary Isidore and intended for John, fell into the
hands of Jerome (§37). The letter showed that Isidore was coming
as a mere partisan of John, and Jerome, therefore, treated both it and
the bearer with secret contempt. The dispute was thus prolonged for
about four years, and, after some attempts at reconciliation, and the
exhibition of much bitterness, amounting to the practical
excommunication of Jerome and his friends, the dispute was stopped,
perhaps by Theophilus, perhaps through the influence of Melania. The
letter written to Pammachius at Rome, in 397 or 398, against John, was
abruptly broken off, and it is almost certain that it was never
published during Jerome’s lifetime. Jerome afterwards had so much
influence with Theophilus that we find him interceding for John, who
had fallen under the Pontiff’s displeasure (Letter LXXXVI.
1).