3. On the other hand, if I were to publish the letter in
which I raise this obscure point without the reply in which it may be
set at rest, it might circulate widely and reach men who
“comparing themselves,” as the Apostle says, “with
themselves,” 2 Cor. x. 12. would
misconstrue a motive which they could not understand, and would explain
my feeling towards one whom I love and esteem for his immense services not as it would appear to them (for
it would be invisible to them) but as their own fancy and malice would
dictate. Now this is a danger which, so far as in me lies, I am bound
to guard against. But if a document which I am unwilling to publish is
published without my consent and placed in hands from which I would
withhold it, then I shall have to resign myself to the will of God.
Indeed, had I wished to keep my words permanently undivulged I should
never have sent them to any one. For if (though I hope it may not be
so) chance or necessity shall prevent any reply being ever given me, my
letter of inquiry is still bound sooner or later to come to light. Nor
will it be useless to those who read it; for, although they will nor
find what they seek, they will learn how much better it is, when one is
uninformed, to put questions than to make assertions; and in the
meantime those whom they consult At this point the
text is obscure. will work
out the points raised by me, laying aside contention and in the
interests of learning and charity trying to obtain sound opinions about
them. Thus they will either arrive at the solutions they desire, or
their faculties will be quickened and they will learn from the
investigation that farther inquiry is useless. At present, however, as
I have no reason to despair of an answer from my friend I have decided
not to publish the letter I have sent him, and I trust, my dear
comrade, that this decision may commend itself to you. It should do so,
for you have not asked for my letter so much as for the answer to it;
and this I would gladly send you if I had it to send. It is true that
in your epistle you speak of “the lucid demonstration of my
wisdom which in virtue of my life the Giver of light has bestowed upon
me”; and if by this you mean not the way in which I have stated
the problem but a solution which I have obtained of the point in
question, I should like to gratify your wish. But I must admit that I
have so far failed to discover how the soul can derive its sin from
Adam (a truth which it is unlawful to question) and yet not itself be
derived from Adam. At present I think it better to sift the matter
farther than to dogmatize rashly.