As we have touched the subject
I deem it not unreasonable to say a few words concerning Easter. It
appears to me that neither the ancients nor moderns who have affected
to follow the Jews, have had any rational foundation for contending so
obstinately about it. For they have not taken into consideration the
fact that when Judaism was changed into Christianity, the obligation to
observe the Mosaic law and the ceremonial types ceased. And the proof
of the matter is plain; for no law of Christ permits Christians to
imitate the Jews. On the contrary the apostle expressly forbids it; not
only rejecting circumcision, but also deprecating contention about
festival days. In his epistle to the Galatians
Gal. iv.
21.
he writes, ‘Tell me ye that desire to be under the law, do ye not
hear the law?’ And continuing his train of argument, he
demonstrates that the Jews were in bondage as servants, but that those
who have come to Christ are ‘called into the liberty of
sons.’
Gal. v.
13.
Moreover he exhorts them in no way to regard ‘days, and months,
and years.’
Gal. iv.
10.
Again in his epistle to the Colossians
Col. ii.
16, 17.
he distinctly declares, that such observances are merely shadows:
wherefore he says, ‘Let no man judge you in meat, or in drink, or
in respect of any holy-day, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath-days;
which are a shadow of things to come.’ The same truths are also
confirmed by him in the epistle to the Hebrews
Heb. vii.
12.
in these words: ‘For the priesthood being changed, there is made
of necessity a change also of the law.’ Neither the apostles,
therefore, nor the Gospels,
ὁ ἀπόστολος…τὰ
ἐυαγγέλια, the
two parts of the New Testament, speaking generally. See
Sophocles’ Greek Lex. of the Rom. and Byzant.
Periods under ἀπόστολος and εὐαγγέλιον
.
have anywhere imposed the ‘yoke of servitude’
Gal. v.
1.
on those who have embraced the truth; but have left Easter and every
other feast to be honored by the gratitude of the recipients of grace.
Wherefore, inasmuch as men love festivals, because they afford them
cessation from labor: each individual in every place, according to his
own pleasure, has by a prevalent custom celebrated the memory of the
saving passion. The Saviour and his apostles have enjoined us by no law
to keep this feast: nor do the Gospels and apostles threaten us with
any penalty, punishment, or curse for the neglect of it, as the Mosaic
law does the Jews. It is merely for the sake of historical accuracy,
and for the reproach of the Jews, because they polluted themselves with
blood on their very feasts, that it is recorded in the Gospels that our
Saviour suffered in the days of ‘unleavened bread.’
Matt. xxvi.
2; Mark xiv. 1; Luke xxii. 1.
The aim of the apostles was not to appoint festival days, but to teach
a righteous life and piety. And it seems to me that just as many other
customs have been established in individual localities according to
usage. So also the feast of Easter came to be observed in each place
according to the individual peculiarities of the peoples inasmuch as
none of the apostles legislated on the matter. And that the observance
originated not by legislation, but as a custom the facts themselves
indicate. In Asia Minor most people kept the fourteenth day of the
moon, disregarding the sabbath: yet they never separated from those who
did otherwise, until Victor, bishop of Rome, influenced by too ardent a
zeal, fulminated a sentence of excommunication against the
Quartodecimans
τεσσαρεσκαιδεκατῖται
, those who observed Easter on the fourteenth day of the lunar month
(Nisan of the Jewish calendar). On the Quartodeciman controversy, see
Schürer, de Centroversiis Paschalibus secundo post Christum
natum Sæculo exortis; also, Salmon, Introduction to the New
Testament, 3 ed. p. 252–267.
in Asia. Wherefore also Irenæus, bishop of Lyons in France,
severely censured Victor by letter for his immoderate heat;
Irenæus, Hær. III. 3, 4.
telling him that although the ancients differed in their celebration of
Easter, they did not desist from intercommunion. Also that Polycarp,
bishop of Smyrna, who afterwards suffered martyrdom under Gordian,
Polycarp suffered martyrdom in 156 a.d. (see Lightfoot, Apostolic Fathers, Part II.
Vol. I. p. 629–702, containing conclusive proof of this, as well
as a history of the question); whence it appears that it was under
Antoninus Pius that he died. Valesius therefore infers that Socrates
meant to speak of Irenæus as suffering martyrdom under Gordian,
and not of Polycarp. If this be the case, we must assume a serious
corruption of the text, or an unparalleled confusion in Socrates.
continued to communicate with Anicetus bishop of Rome, although he
himself, according to the usage of
his native Smyrna, kept Easter on the fourteenth day of the moon, as
Eusebius attests in the fifth book of his Ecclesiastical
History.
Euseb. V. 24.
While therefore some in Asia Minor observed the day above-mentioned,
others in the East kept that feast on the sabbath indeed, but differed
as regards the month. The former thought the Jews should be followed,
though they were not exact: the latter kept Easter after the equinox,
refusing to celebrate with the Jews; ‘for,’ said they,
‘it ought to be celebrated when the sun is in Aries, in the month
called Xanthicus by the Antiochians, and April by the Romans.’ In
this practice, they averred, they conformed not to the modern Jews, who
are mistaken in almost everything, but to the ancients, and to Josephus
according to what he has written in the third book of his Jewish
Antiquities.
Josephus, Antiq. III. 10. The passage is
worth quoting entire, running as follows: ‘In the month
Xanthicus, which is called Nisan by us, and is the beginning of the
year, on the fourteenth day of the moon, while the sun is in the sign
of Aries (the Ram), for during this month we were freed from bondage
under the Egyptians, he has also appointed that we should sacrifice
each year the sacrifice which, as we went out of Egypt, they commanded
us to offer, it being called the Passover.’
Thus these people were at issue among themselves. But all other
Christians in the Western parts, and as far as the ocean itself, are
found to have celebrated Easter after the equinox, from a very ancient
tradition. And in fact these acting in this manner have never disagreed
on this subject. It is not true, as some have pretended, that the Synod
under Constantine altered this festival:
The Audiani, who averred that the Synod of
Nicæa first fixed the time of Easter.
for Constantine himself, writing to those who differed respecting it,
recommended that as they were few in number, they could agree with the
majority of their brethren. His letter will be found at length in the
third book of the Life of Constantine by Eusebius; but the
passage in it relative to Easter runs thus:
Euseb. Life of Constant. III. 19.