26. There is another argument which I shall adduce, and
against that not even Hilary, As Deucalion was
left alone after the flood, so, Jerome implies, Hilary imagined himself
the sole survivor after the flood of Arianism. the modern
Deucalion, will venture to mutter a syllable. If heretics are not
baptized and must be re-baptized because they were not in the Church,
Hilary himself also is not a Christian. For he was baptized in that
Church which always allowed heretical baptism. Before the Synod of
Ariminum was held, before Lucifer went into exile, Hilary when a deacon
of the Roman Church welcomed those who came over from the heretics on
account of the baptism which they had previously received. It can
hardly be that Arians are the only heretics, and that we are to accept
all but those whom they have baptized. You were a deacon, Hilary (the
Church may say), and received those whom the Manichæans had
baptized. You were a deacon, and acknowledged Ebion’s baptism.
All at once after Arius arose you began to be quite out of conceit with
yourself. You and your household separated from us, and opened a new
laver of your own. If some angel or apostle has re-baptized you, I will
not disparage your procedure. But since you who raise your sword
against me are the son of my womb, and nourished on the milk of my
breasts, return to me what I gave you, and be, if you can, a Christian
in some other way. Suppose I am a harlot, still I am your mother. You
say, I do not keep the marriage bed undefiled: still what I am now I
was when you were conceived. If I commit adultery with Arius, I did the
same before with Praxias, with Ebion, with Cerinthus, and Novatus. You
think much of them and welcome them, adulterers as they are, to your
mother’s home. I don’t know why one adulterer more than
others should offend you.