649
identified, the engrafted bough withers, but the life of the tree continues unimpaired. For
there is further a mode of grafting of such a kind, that without cutting away any branch that
is within, the branch that is foreign to the tree is inserted, not indeed without a wound, but
with the slightest possible wound inflicted on the tree. In like manner, then, when they
come to the root which exists in the Catholic Church, without being deprived of any position
which belongs to them as clergy or bishops after ever so deep repentance of their error, there
is a kind of wound inflicted as it were upon the bark of the mother tree, breaking in upon
the strictness of her discipline; but since neither he that planteth is anything, neither he that
watereth,2554 so soon as by prayers poured forth to the mercy of God peace is secured
through the union of the engrafted boughs with the parent stock, charity then covers the
multitude of sins.
45. For although it was made an ordinance in the Church, that no one who had been
called upon to do penance for any offense should be admired into holy orders, or return to
or continue in the body of the clergy,2555 this was done not to cause despair of any indulgence
being granted, but merely to maintain a rigorous discipline; otherwise an argument will be
raised against the keys that were given to the Church, of which we have the testimony of
Scripture: "Whatsoever thou shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."2556 But lest it
should so happen that, after the detection of offenses, a heart swelling with the hope of ec-
clesiastical preferment might do penance in a spirit of pride, it was determined, with great
severity, that after doing penance for any mortal sin, no one should be admitted to the
number of the clergy, in order that, when all hope of temporal preferment was done away,
the medicine of humility might be endowed with greater strength and truth. For even the
holy David did penance for deadly sin, and yet was not degraded from his office. And we
know that the blessed Peter, after shedding the bitterest of tears, repented that he had denied
his Lord, and yet remained an apostle. But we must not therefore be induced to think that
the care of those in later times was in any way superfluous, who, when there was no risk of
endangering salvation, added something to humiliation, in order that the salvation might
be more thoroughly protected,—having, I suppose, experienced a feigned repentance on
the part of some who were influenced by the desire of the power attaching to office. For
experience in many diseases necessarily brings in the invention of many remedies. But in
cases of this kind, when, owing to the serious ruptures of dissensions in the Church, it is no
longer a question of danger to this or that particular individual, but whole nations are lying
2554 1 Cor. iii. 7.
2555 Pope Innocent I., in his 6th Epistle to Agapitus, Macedonius, and Maurianus, bishops of Apulia, writes
to the effect that "canons had been passed at Nicæa, excluding penitents from even the lowest orders of the
ministry" (can. 10).
2556 Matt. xvi. 19.
1288
Chapter 10