9. Since Mr. W. abundantly allows, that visible Christians must be believed in charity
to be truly pious; and that they are such as have the moral image of Christ appearing in
them, and supposed to be in them, and that they are to be loved on that account: therefore
very impertinent and inconsistent is the opposition he makes to my ninth argument, from
the nature of that brotherly love required towards all visible Christians; which was to show,
that visible Christians by the rule of Christ were to be apprehended to be true Christians.
10. In like manner, vain and to no purpose is the opposition he makes to my tenth argu-
ment, from the nature of sacramental actions, supposed in their intent and signification to
be a solemn profession of those things wherein real piety consists, viz. a cordial acceptance
of Christ and his benefits; from thence arguing, that a profession of these things is necessary,
and so inferring, that those who perform these actions, should suppose themselves truly to
accept of Christ: since both these things are in effect granted, that communicants must judge
that they have sanctifying grace, and also that they must profess gospel-holiness, a compliance
with the call of the gospel, and falling in with the terms of salvation proposed, &c.
11. In vain also is the opposition he makes to my eleventh argument, from 1 Cor. xi. 28.
” Let a man examine himself; and so let him eat.”—Inferring from thence, that a man ought
to inquire concerning such a qualification in himself, as grace, in order to know whether
he may come to the sacrament of the Lord’s supper. Since Mr. W. himself plainly supposes
this very thing. That men ought to look at such a qualification in themselves, as grace, and
to inquire whether they have it, in order to determine whether they may present themselves
to christian sacraments.
12. If it be true, according to Mr. W.‘s representation of his own scheme, That persons
may not be admitted to sacraments, but under a notion of their being truly godly, and with
respect to such a character appearing on them; and that persons themselves had need to
look at such a qualification in themselves, and inquire whether they have it, in order to de-
termine whether they may come to sacraments; it must be because if they find they have it
not, they may not come, or (which is the same thing) it is not lawful for them to come. For
it would be ridiculous to say that others must look at such a qualification in them, and must
494
not admit them but from respect to such a character on them; and that they themselves
also must look at such a qualification in themselves, and inquire whether they have it in
order to determine whether they may come; when yet they may come whether they have it
or no, and have as much of a lawful right without it as with it. So that Mr. W. has in effect
determined against himself the grand point, which he himself insists on, as the point in
dispute, according to the true state of the question. And therefore,
13. It follows from the foregoing concessions, that Mr. W. is inconsistent with himself
in all his arguings that men may come to sacraments without such a qualification or character
as that of true piety. Because God has given no certain rule by which sacraments may be
1920
SECTION II. Consequences.