than we possess, though not by ours; and at all events, the question whether it exists is one
which may be solved by our understandings.”
4. If you intend to say this, let me remind you that the mental act we call understanding
is done by us in two ways: either by the mind and reason within itself, as when we understand
that the intellect itself exists; or by occasion of suggestion from the senses, as in the case
above mentioned, when we understand that matter exists. In the first of these two kinds of
acts we understand through ourselves, i.e. by asking instruction of God concerning that
which is within us; but in the second we understand by asking instruction of God regarding
that of which intimation is given to us by the body and the senses. If these things be found
true, no one can by his understanding discover whether that body of which you speak exists
or not, but the person to whom his senses have given some intimation concerning it. If there
be any living creature to which the senses give such intimation, since we at least see plainly
that we are not among the number, I regard the conclusion established which I began to
state a little ago, that the question [about the vehicle of the soul] is one which does not
concern us. I wish you would consider this over and over again, and take care to let me
know the product of your consideration.
538
To Nebridius