the Father’s; so that while many parts of the one are to be condemned, the other must be
exempted from all disapproval; and that, too, when we know, as I said before, that it was
not written by Christ or by His apostles.
7. Hence, as you receive nothing in the Old Testament except the prophecies and the
common precepts of practical morality, which we quoted above, while you set aside circum-
cision, and sacrifices, and the Sabbath and its observance, and the feast of unleavened bread,
why should not we receive nothing in the New Testament but what we find said in honor
and praise of the majesty of the Son, either by Himself or by His apostles, with the proviso,
in the case of the apostles, that it was said by them after reaching perfection, and when no
longer in unbelief; while we take no notice of the rest, which, if said at the time, was the ut-
terance of ignorance or inexperience, or, if not, was added by crafty opponents with a mali-
cious intention, or was stated by the writers without due consideration, and so handed down
as authentic? Take as examples, the shameful birth of Jesus from a woman, His being cir-
cumcised like the Jews, His offering sacrifice like the Gentiles, His being baptized in a humi-
liating manner, His being led about by the devil in the wilderness, and His being tempted
by him in the most distressing way. With these exceptions, besides whatever has been inser-
ted under the pretence of being a quotation from the Old Testament, we believe the whole,
especially the mystic nailing to the cross, emblematic of the wounds of the soul in its passion;
as also the sound moral precepts of Jesus, and His parables, and the whole of His immortal
discourse, which sets forth especially the distinction of the two natures, and therefore must
undoubtedly be His. There is, then, no reason for your thinking it obligatory in me to believe
all the contents of the Gospels; for you, as has been proved, take so dainty a sip from the
Old Testament, that you hardly, so to speak, wet your lips with it.
8. Augustin replied: We give to the whole Old Testament Scriptures their due praise
as true and divine; you impugn the Scriptures of the New Testament as having been tampered
with and corrupted. Those things in the Old Testament which we do not observe we hold
to have been suitable appointments for the time and the people of that dispensation, besides
335
being symbolical to us of truths in which they have still a spiritual use, though the outward
observance is abolished; and this opinion is proved to be the doctrine of the apostolic writ-
ings. You, on the other hand, find fault with everything in the New Testament which you
do not receive, and assert that these passages were not spoken or written by Christ or His
apostles. In these respects there is a manifest difference between us. When, therefore, you
are asked why you do not receive all the contents of the New Testament, but, while you ap-
prove of some things, reject a great many in the very same books as false and spurious inter-
polations, you must not pretend to imitate us in the distinction which we make, reverently
and in faith, but must give account of your own presumption.
9. If we are asked why we do not worship God as the Hebrew fathers of the Old Testa-
ment worshipped Him, we reply that God has taught us differently by the New Testament
571
Faustus fails to understand why he should be required either to accept or…