If, I reply, we admit that
everything in a book which is offensive is corruptly inserted by
others, nothing will remain belonging to the author under whose name
the book passes, but everything can be assigned to those by whom it is
supposed to have been corrupted. But then it will not belong to them
either, since we do not know who they were: and the result will be that
every book belongs to everybody and nothing to any one in particular.
In this confusion which this method of defence introduces, it will be
impossible to convict Marcion of error, or Manichæus or Arius or
Eunomius; because, as soon as we point out a statement of their
unbelief, their disciples will answer that was not what the master
wrote, but was corruptly inserted by his opponents. According to this
principle, this very book of yours will not be yours nor mine. And as
to this very book in which I am making reply to your accusations,
whatever you find fault with in it will be held not be written by me
but by you who now find fault with it. And further, while you assign
everything to the heretics, there will be nothing left which you
can assign to churchmen as their own.