42. For although most authorities read “de
Spiritu,” yet the Greek from which the Latins translated have
“ἐχ
πνεύματος
ἁγίου,” that is,
“ex Spiritu Sancto.” For that which is
“of” [ex] any one is either of his substance or of
his power. Of his substance, as the Son, Who says: “I
came forth of the Mouth of the Most High;” Ecclus. xxiv. 3. as the Spirit, “Who proceedeth from
the Father;” S. John xv. 20. of Whom the Son
says: “He shall glorify Me, for He shall receive of
Mine.” S. John xvi. 14. But of the
power, as in the passage: “One God the Father, of Whom are
all things.” 1 Cor. viii. 6. The argument from the exact
force of prepositions is often urged by the Fathers, as by St.
Athanasius and St. Basil among the Greeks. The Latins also use
it, as St. Ambrose here, but occasionally the same Greek prepositions
are variously rendered, which destroys the force of the argument.
With regard to the two prepositions ex and de St.
Augustine gives a very good explanation, De Natura Bon, c.
27: “Ex ipso [of Him] does not always mean the same
as de ipso [from Him]. That which is from Him can be said
to be of Him, but not everything which is of Him is rightly said to be
from Him. Of Him are the heavens and the earth, for He made them,
but not from Him, because not of His substance.” But
neither the Vulgate nor even St. Ambrose himself is quite consistent in
this matter.