It is
a question to be decided, whether our Lord speaks of actual ignorance
in His human Mind, or of the natural ignorance of that Mind considered
as human; ignorance in or ex natura; or, which comes to
the same thing, whether He spoke of a real ignorance, or of an
economical or professed ignorance, in a certain view of His incarnation
or office, as when He asked, ‘How many loaves have ye?’
when ‘He Himself knew what He would do,’ or as He is called
sin, though sinless. Thus it has been noticed, supr. ii. 55, n.
7, that Ath. seems to make His infirmities altogether only imputative,
not real, as if shewing that the subject had not in his day been
thoroughly worked out. In like manner S. Hilary, who, if the passage be
genuine, states so clearly our Lord’s ignorance, de Trin.
ix. fin. yet, as Petavius observes, seems elsewhere to deny to Him
those very affections of the flesh to which he has there paralleled it.
And this view of Athan.’s meaning is favoured by the turn of his
expressions. He says such a defect belongs to ‘that human
nature whose property it is to be ignorant;’ §43. that
‘since He was made man, He is not ashamed, because of the
flesh which is ignorant, to say, “I know
not;”’ ibid. and, as here, that ‘as shewing
His manhood, in that to be ignorant is proper to man, and that
He had put on a flesh that was ignorant, being in which,
He said according to the flesh, “I know not;”’
‘that He might shew that as man He knows not;’
§46. that ‘as man’ (i.e. on the ground
of being man, not in the capacity of man), ‘He knows
not;’ ibid. and that, ‘He asks about Lazarus
humanly,’ even when ‘He was on His way to raise
him,’ which implied surely knowledge in His human nature. The
reference to the parallel of S. Paul’s professed ignorance when
he really knew, §47. leads us to the same suspicion. And so
‘for our profit as I think, did He this.’
§§48–50. The natural want of precision on such
questions in the early ages was shewn or fostered by such words
as οἰκονομικῶς, which, in respect of this very text, is used by S. Basil
to denote both our Lord’s Incarnation, Ep. 236, 1 fin. and
His gracious accommodation of Himself and His truth, Ep. 8, 6.
and with the like variety of meaning, with reference to the same text,
by Cyril. Trin. p. 623. and Thesaur. p. 224. (And the
word dispensatio in like manner, Ben. note on Hil. x. 8.)
In the latter Ep. S. Basil suggests that our Lord
‘economizes by a feigned ignorance.’ §6. And S. Cyril.
Thesaur. p. 224. And even in de Trin. vi. he seems to
recognise the distinction laid down just now between the natural and
actual state of our Lord’s humanity; and so Hilary, Trin.
ix. 62. And he gives reasons why He professed ignorance, n. 67. viz. as
S. Austin words it, Christum se dixisse nescientem, in quo alios facit
occultando nescientes. Ep. 180, 3. S. Austin follows him,
saying, Hoc nescit quod nescienter facit. Trin. i. 23. Pope
Gregory says that the text ‘is most certainly to be referred to
the Son not as He is Head, but as to His body which we are.’
Ep x. 39. And S. Ambrose de fid. v. 222. And so
Cæsarius, Qu. 20. and Photius Epp. p. 366. Chrysost. in
Matt. Hom. 77, 3. Theodoret, however, but in controversy, is
very severe on the principle of Economy. ‘If He knew the day, and
wishing to conceal it, said He was ignorant, see what a blasphemy is
the result. Truth tells an untruth.’ l. c, pp. 23, 4.