Now the use of the word in Christian theology had
exemplified nearly every one of the above senses. In the quasi-material
sense ὁμοούσιον had been
used in the school of Valentinian to express the homogeneity of the two
factors in the fundamental dualism of the Universe of intelligent
beings. In a somewhat similar sense it is used in the Clementine
Homilies xx. 7. The Platonic phrase for the Divine Nature, ἐπέκεινα
πάσης
οὐσίας, adopted by Origen and by
Athanasius contra Gentes, appears to retain something of the
idea of οὐσία as
implying material existence; and this train of associations had
to be expressly disclaimed in defending the Nicene formula. In the
sense of homogeneity the word ὀμοούσιον is
expressly applied by Origen, as we have seen, to the Father and the
Son: on the other hand, taking οὐσία in the
‘primary’ Aristotelian sense, he has ἕτερος
κατ᾽ οὐσίαν
καὶ
ὑποκειμένον In the West (see above on Tertullian and Novatian)
the Latin substantia (Cicero had in vain attempted to give
currency to the less euphonious but more suitable essentia) had
taken its place in the phrase unius substantiæ
orcommunio substantiæ, intended to denote not only the
homogeneity but the Unity of Father and Son. Accordingly we find
Dionysius of Rome pressing the test upon his namesake of Alexandria and
the latter not declining it (below, p. 183). But a few years later we
find the Origenist bishops, who with the concurrence of Dionysius of
Rome deposed Paul of Samosata, expressly repudiating the term. This
fact, which is as certain as any fact in Church history (see Routh
Rell. iii. 364 &c., Caspari Alte u. Neue. Q., pp. 161
sqq.), was a powerful support to the Arians in their subsequent
endeavours to unite the conservative East in reaction against the
council. Scholars are fairly equally divided as to the explanation of
the fact. Some hold, following Athanasius and Basil, that Paul imputed the ὀμοούσιον (in a
materialising sense) to his opponents, as a consequence of the doctrine
they opposed to his own, and that ‘the 80’ in repudiating
the word, repudiated the idea that the divine nature could be divided
by the emanation of a portion of it in the Logos. Hilary, on the other
hand, tells us that the word was used by Paul himself (‘male
ὀμοούσιον Paulus
confessus est, sed numquid melius Arii negaverunt?’) If so, it
must have been meant to deny the existence of the Logos as an οὐσία (i.e. Hypostasis)
distinct from the Father. Unfortunately we have not the original
documents to refer to. But in either case the word was repudiated at
Antioch in one sense, enacted at Nicæa in another. The fact
however remains that the term does not exclude ambiguity. Athanasius is
therefore going beyond strict accuracy when he claims (p. 164) that no
one who is not an Arian can fail to be in agreement with the Synod.
Marcellus and Photinus alone prove the contrary. But he is right in
regarding the word as rigidly excluding the heresy of Arius.