27. But if anyone thinks it open to question whether
heretics were always welcomed by our ancestors, let him read the
letters of the blessed Cyprian in which he applies the lash to Stephen,
bishop of Rome, and his errors which had grown inveterate by usage. The advocates on
each side could plead immemorial local usage. If imposition of hands
was the rule at Rome, synods held at Iconium and at Synnada had
established the rule of re-baptism nearly throughout Asia Minor. In
Africa the same practice had been sanctioned early in the third
century, but it seems to have fallen into disuse long before
Cyprian’s time. Let him also read the pamphlets of Hilary on the
re-baptization of heretics which he published against us, and he will
there find Hilary himself confessing that Bishops of
Rome—Julius 337–352; Mark Jan. 18–Oct. 7, 336;
Sylvester 314–335.Julius, Marcus, Sylvester, and the other
bishops of old alike welcomed all heretics to repentance; and, further,
to shew that he could not justly claim possession of the true custom;
the Council of Nicæa also, to which we referred not long ago,
welcomed all heretics with the exception of Canon 19. the disciples of Paul of Samosata. And,
what is more, it allows a Novatian bishop on conversion to have the
rank of presbyter, Canon 8. The
bishop might give him the nominal honour of a bishop. a decision
which condemns both Lucifer and Hilary, since the same person who is
ordained is also baptized.