(c) This leads us to the important
observation that momentous as are to Athanasius the consequences of the
introduction of sin into the world, he yet makes no such vast
difference between the condition of fallen and unfallen men as has
commonly been assumed to exist. The latter state was inferior to that
of the members of Christ (Orat. ii. 67, 68), while the immense
(c. Gent. 8, de Incar. 5) consequences of its forfeiture
came about only by a gradual course of deterioration (de Incar.
6. 1, ἠφανίζετο; observe
the tense), and in different degrees in different cases. The only
difference of kind between the two conditions is in the universal reign
of Death since the (partial) forfeiture of the τοῦ κατ᾽
εἰκόνα
χάρις: and even this difference is a
subtle one; for man’s existence in Paradise was not one of ἀφθαρσία except
prospectively (de Incar. 3. 4). He enjoyed present happiness,
ἄλυπος
ἀνώδυνος
ἀμέριμνος
ζωή, with promise of ἀφθαρσία in heaven. That
is, death would have taken place, but not death as unredeemed mankind
know it (cf. de Incar. 21. 1). In other words, man was created
not so much in a state of perfection (τέλειος
κτισθείς, p. 384) as
with a capacity for perfection (and for even more than perfection, p.
385 sq.) and with a destiny to correspond with such capacity.
This destination remains in force even after man has failed to
correspond to it, and is in fact assigned by Athanasius as the reason
why the Incarnation was a necessity on God’s part (de
Incar. 6. 4–7, 10. 3, 13. 2–4, Orat. ii. 66,
&c., &c.). Accordingly, while man was created
(Orat. ii. 59) through the Word, the Word became Flesh that man
might receive the yet higher dignity of Sonship The above
is strikingly illustrated by the discussion (pp. 381–383)
of πρωτότοκος
πάσης
κτίσεως (Col. i. 15). At first sight Ath. appears to contradict himself,
explaining πρωτότοκος
as he does first solely of the Saviour as
Incarnate, and then of the cosmic and creative
function of the Word. But closer examination brings out his view of
creation itself (p. 383) as an act of Grace, demanding not (as the
current Eastern theology held, in common with Arius) the mediation of a
subordinate Creator, but an act of absolutely Divine condescension
analogous to, and anticipatory of, the Incarnation. The apparently
disturbing persistence in the argument of the cosmological explanation
of πρωτότοκος
is really therefore due to a subtle change in it, by
virtue of which it comes into relation with the Soteriological
idea,—which is the pivot of the entire anti-Arian position of
Athanasius on this question,—and with the ultimate scheme in
which (cf. Rom. viii.) the effects of the Incarnation are to embrace the whole
creation. Because creation as such involves the promise of adoption,
and tends to deification as its goal, the Son is πρωτότοκος
in the region of Grace and of Creation
alike.; and
while even before the Incarnation some men were de facto pure
from sin (Orat. iii. 33) by virtue of the χάρις τῆς
κλήσεως involved in ῾τὸ
κατ᾽
εἰκόνα᾽ (see ib.
10, fin.; Orat. i. 39 is even stronger, cf. iv. 22), they
were yet θνητοί
and φθαρτοί;
whereas those in Christ die, no longer κατὰ τὴν
προτέραν
γένεσιν ἐν τῷ
᾽Αδάμ, but to live again λογωθείσης
τῆς σαρκός
(Orat. iii. 33, fin., cf. de Incar. 21. 1).