The distinction, which in the foregoing
discussion we have frequently had under our notice, between the πίστις and γνῶσις of the early Church,
the πίστις common
to all, and formulated in the tessera or rule of faith, the
γνῶσις the
property of apologists and theologians aiming at the expression of
faith in terms of the thought of their age, and at times, though for
long only slightly, reacting upon the rule of faith itself (Aquileia,
Cæsarea, Gregory Thaumaturgus), makes itself felt in the account
of the Nicene Council. That the legacy of the first world-wide
gathering of the Church’s rulers is a Rule of Faith moulded by
theological reflexion, one in which the
γνῶσις of the Church supplements her
πίστις, is a
momentous fact; a fact for which we have to thank not Athanasius but
Arius. The πίστις
of the Fathers repudiated Arianism as a novelty; but to exclude it from
the Church some test was indispensable; and to find a test was the task
of theology, of γνῶσις. The Nicene
Confession is the Rule of Faith explained as against Arianism. Arianism
started with the Christian profession of belief in our Lord’s
Sonship. If the result was incompatible with such belief, it was
inevitable that an explanation should be given, not indeed of the full
meaning of divine Sonship, but of that element in the idea which was
ignored or assailed by the misconception of Arius. Such an explanation
is attempted in the words ἐκ τῆς οὐσίας
τοῦ πατρός,
ὁμοούσιαν τῷ
Πατρί, and again in the condemnation
of the formula ἐξ
ἑτέρας
ὑποστάσεως ἢ
οὐσίας. This explanation was not
adopted without hesitation, nor would it have been adopted had any
other barrier against the heresy, which all but very few wished to
exclude, appeared effective. We now have to examine firstly the grounds
of this hesitation, secondly the justification of the formula
itself.