or Motion, that a man born blind might form, it would be nothing like what we call by those
names. All that he could have would be only certain sensations or feelings, that in themselves
would be no more like what we intend by Space, Motion, &c. than the pain we have by the
scratch of a pin, or that the ideas of taste and smell. And as to the idea of Motion, that such
a one could have, it could be only a diversification of those successions in a certain way, by
succession as to time. And then there would be an agreement of these successions of sensa-
tions, with some ideas we have by sight, as to number and proportions; but yet the ideas,
after all, nothing akin to that idea we now give this name to.—And, as it is very plain, Colour
is only in the mind, and nothing like it can be out of all mind. Hence it is manifest, there
can be nothing like those things we call by the name of Bodies, out of the mind, unless it be
in some other mind or minds.
And, indeed, the secret lies here: That, which truly is the Substance of all Bodies, is the
infinitely exact, and precise, and perfectly stable Idea, in God’s mind, together with his stable
Will, that the same shall gradually be communicated to us, and to other minds, according to
certain fixed and exact established Methods and Laws: or in somewhat different language,
the infinitely exact and precise Divine Idea, together with an answerable, perfectly exact,
precise, and stable Will, with respect to correspondent communications to Created Minds,
and effects on their minds.
[61.] Substance. 104 It is intuitively certain, that , if Solidity be removed from Body,
nothing is left but empty space. Now, in all things whatsoever, that which cannot be removed
without removing the whole thing, that thing which is removed is the thing itself, except it
be mere circumstance and manner of existence, such as Time and Place; which are in the
general necessary, because it implies a contradiction to existence itself, to suppose that it
exists at no time and in no place, and therefore in order to remove time and place in the
general, we must remove the thing itself: So if we remove Figure and Bulk and Texture, in
the general; which may be reduced to that necessary circumstance of Place.
If, therefore, it implies a contradiction to suppose that body, or any thing appertaining
to Body, beside Space, exists, when Solidity is removed; it must be, either because Body is
nothing but Solidity and Space, or else, that Solidity is such a mere circumstance and relation
of existence, which the thing cannot be without, because whatever exists must exist in some
circumstances or other, as at some time or some place. But we know, and every one perceives,
it to be a contradiction to suppose, that Body or Matter exists without Solidity, for all the
notion we have of Empty Space, is Space without Solidity, and all the notion we have of Full
Space, is Space Resisting.
104 This article, and the numbers following, viz. 62, 63. &c. are inserted in the manuscript distinctly from
the rest, and were written probably at a somewhat later period of life.
473
NO.IV. Remarks in Mental Philosophy. The Mind.