It is curious that besides the Caroline Books and the
second canon of Frankfort, another matter of great difficulty springs
up with regard to the subject of the authority of the Seventh
Synod. In 1596 there appeared what claims to be an ancient
account of a convention of bishops in Paris in the year 824. This is reprinted in
full in Mansi, and from him in Migne’s Pat. Lat., Tom.
XCVIII., col. 1299, et seqq. Cardinal Bellarmine’s
refutation is also found in Migne’s Charlemagne, and in Labbe and
Cossart, Tom. VII., of the Concilia. The point in which this interests us
is that the bishops at this meeting are supposed to have condemned the
Seventh Council, and to have approved the Caroline books. The
whole story was rejected by Cardinal Bellarmine and he promptly wrote a
refutation. Sismondi accepted this view of the matter, and Labbe
has excluded the pretended proceedings from his “Concilia”
altogether.