There are, of course, many
points in which S. Gregory falls short of his great predecessor; but of
these some may perhaps be accounted for by the different aspect of the
Arian controversy as it presented itself to the two champions of the
Faith. The later school of Arianism may indeed be regarded as a
perfectly legitimate and rigidly logical development of the doctrines
taught by Arius himself; but in some ways the task of S. Gregory was a
different task from that of S. Athanasius, and was the less formidable
of the two. His antagonist was, by his own greater definiteness of
statement, placed at a disadvantage: the consequences which S.
Athanasius had to extract from the Arian statements were by Eunomius
and the Anomœans either openly asserted or tacitly admitted: and
it was thus an easier matter for S. Gregory to show the real tendency
of Anomœan doctrine than it had been for S. Athanasius to point
out the real tendency of the earlier Arianism. Further, it may be said
that by the time of S. Basil, still more by the time when S. Gregory
succeeded to his brother’s place in the controversy, the victory
over Arianism was assured. It was not possible for S. Athanasius, even
had it been in his nature to do so, to treat the earlier Arianism with
the same sort of contemptuous criticism with which Eunomius is
frequently met by S. Gregory. For S. Gregory, on the other hand, it was
not necessary to refrain from such criticism lest he should thereby
detract from the force of his protest against error. The crisis in his
day was not one which demanded the same sustained effort for which the
contest called in the days of S. Athanasius. Now and then, certainly,
S. Gregory also rises to a white heat of indignation against his adversary: but it
is hardly too much to say that his work appears to lack just those
qualities which seem, in the writings of S. Athanasius, to have been
called forth by the author’s sense of the weight of the force
opposed to him, and of the “life and death” character of
the contest. S. Gregory does not under-estimate the momentous nature of
the questions at issue: but when he wrote, he might feel that to those
questions the answer of Christendom had been already given, that the
conflict was already won, and that any attempt at developing the Arian
doctrine on Anomœan lines was the adoption of an untenable
position,—even of a position manifestly and evidently untenable:
the doctrine had but to be stated in clear terms to be recognized as
incompatible with Christianity, and, that fact once recognized, he had
no more to do. Thus much of his treatises against Eunomius consists not
of constructive argument in support of his own position, but of a
detailed examination of Eunomius’ own statements, while a further
portion of the contents of these books, by no means inconsiderable in
amount, is devoted not so much to the defence of the Faith as to the
refutation of certain misrepresentations of S. Basil’s arguments
which had been set forth by Eunomius.