This view of Rebecca’s conduct is generally
sanctioned by the Fathers: so St. Augustin: “That which Jacob
did by direction of his mother so as to appear to deceive his
father, if you consider it diligently and faithfully, ‘non est
mendacium sed mysterium.’ And if we term that sort of thing a
lie, by the same rule we must also account as lies all parables and
figures whatsoever.” contr. Mendac. ad Consentium, c.
24. St. Ambrose, (de Jacob et vita beata, ii. 6.) “In
the mind of that pious mother the mystery overweighed the tie of
affection. She was not so much preferring Jacob to his brother,
as offering him to the Lord, who, she knew, had power to preserve
the gift presented unto Him.” This seems to mean that in
consecrating Jacob to be the first-born, she knowingly separated
him from herself, and so made a greater sacrifice. S. Chrys.
himself says, “Rebecca did this not of her own mind, but in
obedience to the divine oracle,” (on Gen. Hom. liii. 1.
414.) And he proceeds to point out God’s hand in certain minute
details of the transaction. It appears from St. Jerome, (1.169.)
that Hippolytus, Irenæus’ disciple, early in the third century,
took the same view. St. Gregory Nazianzen seems to be the only
writer who has left a contrary judgment on record: saying, “he
pursued a noble object by ignoble means.” The general result of
the reflections of the Fathers on the subject seems to be, that as
where we have God’s express command or approbation, we are sure
of the rectitude of what would otherwise be wrong, so there may be
circumstances rendering such command or approbation more or less
“probable,” which ought at least to stay us from censure: and
that marked providential interference, and mysterious allusion,
throughout, are to be considered as such circumstances.
[In the foregoing note the translator
has correctly stated the patristic view of Rebecca’s conduct, a
view which most moderns heartily reject as dishonoring to God and
of evil influence upon his people. But while we cannot with
Chrysostom cite the wife of Jacob as an example of love, yet there
is some extenuation for her. The case is neatly stated by the
Bishop of Ely in the Speaker’s Commentary. “Rebekah had no
doubt treasured up the oracle which had assured her, even before
their birth, that her younger son Jacob whom she loved should bear
rule over Esau, whose wild and reckless life and whose Canaanitish
wives had been a bitterness of soul to her. She probably knew
that Jacob had bought Esau’s birthright. Now believing rightly
that the father’s benediction would surely bring blessing with
it, she fears that these promises and hopes would fail. She
believed but not with that faith which can patiently abide till God
works out his plans by His providence. So she strove, as it were,
to force forward the event by unlawful means; even, as some have
thought that Judas betrayed Christ that he might free Him to
declare Himself a king and take the kingdom.” Every character
in the history comes in for some share of blame, but the greatest
seems due to her who originated the whole plot, who swept away the
scruples of her favorite son, and taught him to perpetrate the
boldest fraud and falsehood upon his venerable father. The
overweening idolatrous affection which led to such doings is very
different from the love which the Apostle inculcates and praises.
C.]