Introductory Notice
to the
Pseudo-Clementine
Literature.
By Professor M. B. Riddle,
D.D.
————————————
The
name
“Pseudo-Clementine Literature” (or, more briefly,
“Clementina”) is applied to a series of writings, closely
resembling each other, purporting to emanate from the great Roman
Father. But, as Dr. Schaff remarks, in this literature he is
evidently confounded with “Flavius Clement, kinsman of the
Emperor Domitian.”
504
These writings
are three in number: (1) the
Recognitions
, of which only
the Latin translation of Rufinus has been preserved;
505
(2) the
Homilies
, twenty in number, of which a complete
collection has been known since 1853; (3) the
Epitome
, “an
uninteresting extract from the
Homilies
, to which are added
extracts from the letter of Clement to James, from the
Martyrium
of Clement by Simeon Metaphrastes, etc.”
506
Other writings may be classed with these; but they are of the same
general character, except that most of them show the influence of a
later age, adapting the material more closely to the orthodox
doctrine.
The
Recognitions
and the
Homilies
appear in the pages which follow. The former are given a prior
position, as in the Edinburgh series. It probably cannot be
proven that these represent the earlier form of this theological
romance; but the
Homilies
, “in any case, present the more
doctrinally developed and historically important form of the other
treatises, which are essentially similar.”
507
They are therefore with propriety
placed after the
Recognitions
, which do not seem to have been
based upon them, but upon some earlier document.
508
The critical discussion of the
Clementina
has been keen, but has not reached its end. It necessarily
involves other questions, about which there is still great difference
of opinion. A few results seem to be
established:—
(1) The entire literature is of
Jewish-Christian, or Ebionitic, origin. The position accorded to
“James, the Lord’s brother,” in all the writings, is
a clear indication of this; so is the silence respecting the Apostle
Paul. The doctrinal statements, “though not perfectly
homogeneous” (Uhlhorn), are Judaistic, even when mixed with
Gnostic speculation of heathen origin. This tendency is, perhaps,
not so clearly marked in the
Recognitions
as in the
Homilies
; but both partake largely of the same general
character. More particularly, the literature has been connected
with the Ebionite sect called the Elkesaites; and some regard the
Homilies
as containing a further development of their
system.
509
This is not definitely established, but
finds some
support in
the resemblance between the baptismal forms, as given by Hippolytus in
the case of the Elkesaites,
510
and those indicated in
the
Recognitions
and
Homilies
, especially the
latter.
511
(2) The entire literature belongs to the
class of fictitious writing “with a purpose.” The
Germans properly term the
Homilies
a
“Tendenz-Romance.” The many “lives of
Christ” written in our day to insinuate some other view of our
Lord’s person than that given in the canonical Gospels, furnish
abundant examples of the class. The Tübingen school, finding
here a real specimen of the influence of party feeling upon
quasi-historical literature, naturally pressed the
Clementina
in
support of their theory of the origin of the Gospels.
(3) The discussion leaves it quite probable,
though not yet certain, that all the works are “independent
elaborations—perhaps at first hand, perhaps at second or
third—of some older tract not now extant.”
512
Some of the opinions held respecting
the relations of the two principal works are given by the Edinburgh
translator in his Introductory Notice. It is only necessary here
to indicate the progress of the modern discussion. Neander, as
early as 1818, gave some prominence to the doctrinal view of the
Homilies
. He was followed by Baur, who found in these
writings, as indicated above, support for his theory of the origin of
historical Christianity. It is to be noted, however, that the
heterogeneous mixture of Ebionism and Gnosticism in the doctrinal views
proved perplexing to the leader of the Tübingen school.
Schliemann
513
took ground against
Baur, collecting much material, and carefully investigating the
question. Both authors give the priority to the
Homilies
. While Baur went too far in one direction,
Schliemann, perhaps, failed to recognise fully the basis of truth in
the position of the former. The next important step in the
discussion was made by Hilgenfeld,
514
whose views are
briefly given in the Notice which follows. Hilgenfeld assigned
the priority to the
Recognitions
, though he traced all the
literature to an earlier work. Uhlhorn
515
at
first attempted to prove that the
Recognitions
were a revision
of the
Homilies
. Further contributions were made by
Lehmann
516
and Lipsius.
517
The former discovered in the
Recognitions
two distinct parts by different authors
(i.–iii., iv.–ix.), tracing all the literature to the
Kerygma
of Peter. The latter finds the basis of the whole
in the
Acta Petri
, which show a strong anti-Pauline
tendency.
Influenced by these investigations, Uhlhorn
modified his views. Lechler,
518
while not
positive in his convictions, makes the following prudent
statement: “An older work lies at the basis both of the
Homilies
and
Recognitions
, bearing the title,
Kerygmen
des Petrus
.
519
To this
document sometimes the
Homilies
, sometimes the
Recognitions
, correspond more faithfully; its historical
contents are more correctly seen from the
Recognitions
, its
doctrinal contents from the
Homilies
.” Other views,
some of them quite fanciful, have been presented.
The prevalent opinion necessarily leaves us in ignorance
of the authors of this literature. The date of composition, or
editing, cannot be definitely fixed. In their present form the
several works may be as old as the first half of the third century, and
the common basis may be placed in the latter half of the second
century.
How far the anti-Pauline tendency is carried, is a
matter of dispute. Baur and many others think Simon is meant to
represent Paul;
520
but this is difficult
to believe, though we must admit
the disposition to ignore the Apostle to the
Gentiles. As to the literary merit of these productions the
reader must judge.
For convenience in comparison of the two works,
the following table has been prepared, based on the order of the
Recognitions
. The correspondences are not exact, and the
reader is referred to the footnotes for fuller details. This
table gives a general view of the arrangement of the two
narratives:—
Recognitions……Homilies
I.……I., II.
II., III.……III.
———……IV.–VII.
IV.……VIII., IX.
V.……X., XV.
VI.……XI.
VII.……XII., XIII.
VIII., IX.……XIV., XV.
———……XVI.–XIX.
X.……XX.
504
History of the
Christian Church
, vol. ii. p. 436, new edition.
505
See the Introductory Note
of the Edinburgh translator.
506
Uhlhorn, article
Clementines
, Schaff-Herzog, i. p. 497. A second
Epitome
has been published by Dressel; see Introductory Notice
to
Homilies
.
507
Lechler,
Apostolic and Post-Apostolic Times
, ii. p. 268, Edinburgh
translation, 1886, from 3rd edition.
508
Uhlhorn; see
infra
.
509
Comp. Uhlhorn, p.
392; Schaff,
History
, ii. p. 436; Lechler, ii. p. 288. See
Schaff-Herzog, i. art.
Elkesaites
.
510
See Hippolytus,
Refutation of all Heresies
, book ix. 8–12,
Ante-Nicene
Fathers
, vol. v. pp. 131–134. The forms occur in chap.
10, pp. 132, 133.
511
See
Recognitions
, i. 45–48;
Homilies,
Epistle of Peter
to James, 4, Homily XIV. 1.
512
This is the last
opinion of Uhlhorn (Herzog,
Real-Encykl.
, 1877, art.
Clementinen
; comp. Schaff-Herzog, i. p. 498). This author
had previously defended the priority of the
Homilies
(
Die Homilien und Rekognitionen des Clemens
Romanus
, Göttingen, 1854; comp. Herzog, edition
of 1854, art.
Clementinen
).
513
Die
Clementinen nebst den verwandten Schriften, und der
Ebionitismus
, Hamburg, 1844.
514
Die
Clementinischen Rekognitionen und Homilien, nach ihrem Ursprung und
Inhalt dargestellt
, Jena, 1848.
515
See
supra
,
note 3. Uhlhorn found the nucleus of the literature in
Homilies
, xvi.–xix.
516
Die
Clementinischen Schriften
, Gotha, 1869.
517
Die
Quellen der römischen Petrussage
, Kiel, 1872.
518
Apostolic and
Post-Apostolic Times
, vol. ii. p. 270.
519
So Hilgenfeld, Lehmann,
Uhlhorn.
520
See especially
Homilies
, xvii. 19. Here there is “probably only an
incidental sneer at Paul” (Schaff,
History
, ii. p.
438).