Chapter IX.
St. Ambrose questions the heretics and exhibits their answer, which is, that the Son ex-
isted, indeed, before all time, yet was not co-eternal with the Father, whereat the Saint shows
that they represent the Godhead as changeable, and further, that each Person must be believed
to be eternal.
58. Tell me, thou heretic,—for the surpassing clemency of the Emperor grants me this
indulgence of addressing thee for a short space, not that I desire to confer with thee, or am
greedy to hear thy arguments, but because I am willing to exhibit them,—tell me, I say,
whether there was ever a time when God Almighty was not the Father, and yet was God. “I
say nothing about time,” is thy answer. Well and subtly objected! For if thou bringest time
into the dispute, thou wilt condemn thyself, seeing that thou must acknowledge that there
was a time when the Son was not, whereas the Son is the ruler and creator of time.1004 He
cannot have begun to exist after His own work. Thou, therefore, must needs allow Him to
be the ruler and maker of His work.
211
59. “I do not say,” answerest thou, “that the Son existed not before time; but when I call
Him “Son,” I declare that His Father existed before Him, for, as you say, father exists before
son.”1005 But what means this? Thou deniest that time was before the Son, and yet thou wilt
1004 Time. We should take this term in its fullest meaning, as signifying all that exists in time—the created
universe, and all that therein has been, and is, and is to come.
1005 The Arians fell into the popular error of supposing that a father, as a father, existed before his son. They
also required men to apply to Divine Persons, what only holds good of human beings—to impose on the Being
of God those limits to which human existences (as objective facts) are subjected. The existence of the Divine
Father and the Divine Son is without, beyond, above time—with the Godhead there is neither past nor future,
but an everlasting present. But with man, time-categories are necessary forms of thought—everything is seen
as past, present, or to come—and to the human consciousness all objects are presented in time, though the
spiritual principle in man which perceives objects as related in succession, is itself supra-temporal, beholding
succession, but not itself in succession. Now it can hardly be denied with any show of reason that a man is not
a father until his son begins to exist, is born, though the father, as a person distinct from his son, is in existence
before the latter. Again, father and son must be of the same nature—they must both possess the elementary,
essential attributes of humanity. Otherwise there is no fatherhood, no sonship, properly speaking.God has revealed
Himself as a Father—even in the pagan mythologies we see the idea of Fatherhood implicit in Godhead. If the
gods of the heathen did not beget after their kind, they begat heroes and demigods. But created existences cannot
claim to be the first and proper object of the Divine Father’s love. They are for a time only, and with them
Eternal Love could not be satisfied. If God be a true Father, then, He must beget His Like—His Son must be
equal to Him in nature, that is, what is true of the Father, what is essential in the Father, as God, must be true
or essential in the Son also. Therefore the son must be divine, eternal. But the generation (γέννησις) of the Son
is not an event in time. It is a fact, a truth, out of, beyond time, belonging to the divine and eternal and spiritual,
Chapter IX. St. Ambrose questions the heretics and exhibits their answer, which is, that the Son existed, indeed, before all time, yet was not co-eternal with the Father, whereat the Saint shows that they represent the Godhead as changeable, and further, that each Person must be believed to be eternal.
466
Chapter IX. St. Ambrose questions the heretics and exhibits their answer,…