When] Gr. Where. tempted] When they tempted me by calling into question my presence, power and providence, Psalms 78:20. me] That is, Christ, 1 Corinthians 10:9. proved] Out of unbelief, notwithstanding they had experience of my power and presence with them. and saw] Or, notwithstanding they saw. fourtie yeers] See Psalms 95:9.