JasTHE ROYAL LAW
James 2:8-13
8 Howbeit.---This word, (not translated in the King James' Version), from the Greek mentoi, indicates the connection between that which follows, and that which precedes it, in the text. It appears to be used adversatively, and to imply. that James' readers were attempting to justify their conduct toward the rich on the ground that they were simply obeying the royal law of love which requires one to love one's neighbor as one's self. In this event, the statement is to be understood in the light of the following facts: The writer had condemned all undue regard for men simply because they are rich. The disciples might say, in reply: "Our regard for them is no more than we are expected to exhibit, in view of the fact that the law requires us to love our neighbor as our selves." The apostle answers: "It is good if you keep the law; however, since your neighbors include those both rich and poor, why have you honored those who are rich, and have despised the poor? It is all very well to plead the law in justification of your acts, but 'If ye have respect of persons, ye commit sin, being convicted by the law as transgressors.' Thus, the very law which you offer as justification of your act condemns you because it forbids respect of persons, and so convicts you of being transgressors of the law."
Less likely is the view that the statement is designed merely to confirm what had earlier been penned. Favoritism· and partiality toward the rich, and a corresponding disregard for the poor, by Christians, is a violent perversion of the law of love, and is thus sinful. In this event, the meaning would be: "If you really fulfill the royal law, which requires you to love your neighbor as yourself, it is good; but, if you continue to show respect of persons, as you have been doing by favoring the rich and dishonoring the poor, you commit sin, and transgress the law of God yourselves." The law, which they affected to observe, positively for. bade all such distinctions: "Thou shalt not wrest jutstice: thou shalt not respect persons; neither shalt thou take a bribe; for a bribe doth blind the eyes of the wise, and pervert the yvords of the righteous." (Deuteronomy 16:19-20.) It is highly inconsistent to cite the law in justification of one's actions in one matter, and disregard and violate the law in another matter.
if ye fulfil the royal law, according to the Scriptures,---"Fulfil," (teleite, present active indicative of teleo, to bring to completion, perfect, fill full), designates the obligation all sustain to the law. It is our responsibility to permit it to accomplish in us its futl purpose, and to see to it that its requirements are met as fully as it is possible for us so to do. "I£ ye fulfil," is a condition of the first class, and thus the conclusion which follows is assumed to be true; i.e., if the law is fulfilled, "ye do well." It is always well to do right. One who fulfills the law does right. James' readers might properly feel secure in any course which involved fulfilling the law. In showing respect of persons, however, they were not fulfilling the law; they were, instead, disobeying it which forbade all such distinctions.
That which Christians are to fulfill is the "royal Law," (noinon basilikon), a kingly law. Why is it thus designated? There are numerous reasons why it may be so described. ( 1) It is the law of the kingdom of Christ ; and, in summary, involves man's entire duty to those about him ; (2) it is a law which originates with the King of the universe ; (3) it stands at the head of all other laws respecting man's obligation to his fellows; (4) it surpasses in nobility, all other obligations, and leads to the fulfillment of all others. (Galatians 6:2.) Thus, whether James meant that it is a law such as is proper even for kings to follow : or, that it is the king of all other laws, his purpose is quite obvious, the design being to indicate the supreme position which this law should have in the hearts and lives of us all. Notwithstanding its greatness, it must be obeyed; and, any action which violates its spirit, such as favoritism for the rich, because they are rich, is a violation of it.
Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself,---This is a portion (by no means all) of the "royal law," and that portion especially involved in the matter under discussion-respect of persons. This law is timeless in nature, it being incorporated in the law of Moses (Leviticus 19:18), and confirmed, sanctioned and made a part of the New Covenant by our Lord. (Luke IO : 28.) Jesus, indeed, taught that love is at the base of every duty, whether to God or man. In response to the lawyer's query, "Teacher, which is the great commandment of the Jaw?" Jesus answered, "Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with· all thy mind. This is the great and first commandment. And a second like unto it is this, Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. On these two commandments the whole law hangeth, and the prophets." (Matthew 22:35-40.) Let us imagine a nail driven into the wall, and a string draped over it, the two ends hanging downward.
Let one of these strings represent the command to love God supremely; the other, our neighbor as ourselves. Jesus tells us that these two conunandments hold up all that is in the law and the prophets. The law, comprising the five books of Moses, constitutes a vast segment of the Old Testament; and, when to this is added the prophets, major and minor, the mass is greatly enlarged; yet, the Lord declares that these two embrace the whole of the law and the prophets. The meaning is that these two duties are so comprehensive they sum up, and include, all else. He who loves God supremely will discharge fully his duty to God; he who loves his neighbor as himself will, in similar fashion, perform every obligation owed to his neighbor. A Gentile, desiring to make fun of the tremendous mass of material assembled by the Jews in their traditions, once said to a rabbi, "Rabbi, teach me the law, provided you can do so while standing on one foot!" (The Gentile felt that the eminent scholar could not long speak in this position!) The rabbi answered, "Love God with all your heart, mind, strength and soul; and your neighbor as yourself; that is all of the law; the rest is mere commentary."
The first appearance of the statement, "Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thy self," is in the Old Testan1ent (Leviticus 19:18), but Jesus quoted, confirmed and ratified it, and made it a part of the "law of liberty" applicable to us today. (Matthew 18:19; Matthew 22:34-40; Luke 10:26-28; Mark 12:28-34.) It is significant that Jesus designated, as the foundation of all true religion, these basic principles involving love for God and man which, when properly observed, lead to the performance of every duty in both spheres, and neither of which was a part of the decalogue (the ten commandments). It is noteworthy that Jesus said, "Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thy self,"-not instead of thyself! It is not wrong for one to entertain proper regard for one's self; indeed, this becomes the standard by which we are to gauge our actions toward others. It is the application of the Golden Rule to life; which, when faithfu,lly followed, will prompt to the performance of every duty owed. "And as ye would that men should do to you, do ye also to them likewise." (Luke 6:31.)
ye do well:---Your actions are approved and are above reproach. Far from being subjects of rebuke, as in the case involving an unseemly attitude toward the rich, if you obey the royal law which bids you to love your neighbor as yourselves, you shall enjoy the approbation of both God and men. To love others less than we love ourselves is to fail to measure to the standard offered; and, he who fails so to do, is in disobedience to him who erected the standard; i.e., to God himself. Hence, to fall short of this requirement is to be deficient in the performance of duty to God and man. On the other hand, he who properly fulfills his obligation in this area, will be blessed in the fact that in doing his duty to his neighbor he is also obeying God. (1 Peter 2:20.) Compare, also, Philippians 4:14; 1 Corinthians 7:7; and Acts 10:3. Any action, which has, as its design, the fulfillment of the law of God, is excellent; James had no word of condemnation for any who thus did; it was the violation of the law of love (as evidenced in favoritism for the rich and contempt for the poor) being practiced by those to whom he wrote which occasioned his treatment of the matter.
One does not obey one portion of the law of God by disobeying another; and, it is highly inconsistent to quote one law in an effort to justify the violation of another law. Balaam, who wanted to see what the Lord had more to say, has had imitators in every age and dispensation. (Numbers 22:1-41.)
9 but if ye have respect of persons,---(ei de prosopolepteite, condition of the first class, and thus assumed a£ true that they were doing this), the verb of which is. from the same root as the noun in James 2:1. It means to judge people on the basis of outward appearance, rather than on the condition of the heart. The Greek verb is a compound term, occurring no where else in the New Testament, and signifying, literally, face-accepting. This, those to whom James wrote, were doing, in the contrasting attitudes they were exhibiting toward the rich and the poor. This is not an unusual attitude on the part of people of the world. Many are much more interested in what people appear to be, than in what they really are.
The accidental circumstances of life, including wealth, fame, social position, and the like, are to many people of greater value than the enduring qualities of the soul and of the heart. To honor one person more than another simply because one has material means, and the other does not, is to be "face-accepting," and is sinful.
ye commit sin,---(hamartian ergazesthe), literally, "Ye work sin," you participate habitually in it. It was not an occasional lapse into the very human weaknesses, of which J arnes deals; it was a deliberate and calculated course of action which these disciples followed in fawning upon the rich and in showing contempt and disregard for the poor. Moreover, it was not simply or merely a "fault," in which they were engaging; it is by James designated as sin. The word "sin," being without the article in the Greek text, signifies it in the abstract; they were not only committing acts of sin (earlier described), they were in sin, in the practice which the writer so severely condemns.
being convicted by the law as transgressors.-The law which bade them to love their neighbor as themselves convicted them in their practice, inasmuch as it forbade all respect of persons. (Leviticus 19:15.) It was therefore, not possible for them properly to appeal to the law in support of their conduct, since the law to which they would thus appeal, condemned them. To transgress, is to cross over; i.e., to violate; sin is the transgression of the law. (1 John 3:4.) Thus, when these to whom James wrote violated such laws as that set out in Leviticus 19:15 (forbidding respect of persons), they demonstrated themselves to be sinners. However much they may have adhered to the law in other matters, in this respect they stood condemned by it. The conditions of one who thus does is clearly indicated in the verse following.
10 For whosoever shall keep the whole law,---"For," (gar), introduces the reason for the conclusion drawn in the verse preceding. "Whosoever shall keep..." is an indefinite relative clause, the verb of which ("shall keep," aorist active subjunctive of tereo, to guard), means to observe carefully with the view of adhering tenaciously to that which is kept; "the law," is the royal law earlier mentioned, and summed up, as it relates to duties by men to men, in the edict, "Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thy self." The argument of James here appears to be this: "You appeal, for support for your practice (in showing special regard for rich people), to the law which you claim to be observing. But, if you are to justify your action by the law, you must keep the law perfectly. It is most incon!?istent for you to claim justification for your acts by quoting the law, when your actions are flagrant violations of this same law which you affect to follow, with reference to showing respect of persons. (Leviticus 19:18.)
and yet stumble in one point,---"Stumble," (ptaisei, first aorist active subjunctive of ptaio, to trip,) denotes a lapse from that which is right. (James 3:2; Romans 11:1.) It will be observed that the word "point," in our English text, is in italics, thus indicating that there is no corresponding word for it in the Greek text. "Trip, moreover, in one," is the literal rendering of the phrase; however, the context clearly shows that some such word is needed to complete the sense. One might properly translate, ''Stumble in one precept."
he is become guilty of all.---"He"; i.e., the one who claims to be keeping all of the law, and yet is violating one of its precepts. Such a one has become guilty ( gegonen, second perfect indicative of ginoniai, stands guilty) of all. That is, the position which he occupies is that of one who is guilty of all. All of what? Certainly not guilty of having transgressed every specific commandment of the law. Obviously, one who steals does not, by such an act, become a murderer; one who lies does not, in so doing, become a drunkard. How then does one become guilty of "all,"' by violating one precept of the law? The meaning is, he stands condemned by all of the law when he violates any portion of it.
This principle is universally recognized. Some members of our society are styled criminals. These are those who violate the law of the land. What makes them criminals? Their infractions of the law. How much of the law? Any portion thereof. A murderer is no less a criminal because his only crime is murder.
He need not to this add other violations of the law in order to acquire this classification. A lawbreaker is one who breaks the law. There may be, and doubtless often is, but one law involved ; nonetheless, such a person is properly regarded as a lawbreaker. What is the relationship of such a person to the law? He is a law violator. While one must keep all of the law to be lawful; one need break only one precept of it to be a law violator. Thus, one may keep much of the law with great consistency, yet violate one portion of it, and stand condemned by the law as a breaker of it. To illustrate: A flock of sheep in a pasture surrounded by a paneled fence are in the pasture.
If they leap over one of the panels, they are out of the pasture. It is, of course, not necessary for them to leap over every section of the fence around the pasture to be outside. One leap puts them out. Similarly, one violation of God's law, unforgiven, puts one in the position of being condemned by it as a violator of it; disobedience to one precept puts the person who thus does in an area outside that which is characteristic of those who keep it.
The vital lesson taught here is that all of the law of God is pertinent to us, and that we must not feel at liberty to tamper with any portion thereof. He who seeks to pass judgment on the validity of God's laws, and to regard some as essential and others as unnecessary, is most presumptuous, and has officiously invaded the realm of God. One does not justify the violation of one law, by citing another observed. It is not a valid defense against the charge of theft that one did not get drunk, slander another, or commit murder. Obedience to God's law involves submission of the will. Those who keep only such laws as those which they approve, or in which they find satisfaction, have repudiated the will of God, and stubstituted their own.
Such a disposition is presumption of the most objectionable type. It is not our prerogative and privilege to pass judgment on the propriety of any law of God. The fact that they are his is sufficient reason for unquestioned obedience thereto. God's will must be obeyed, not because it commends itself to our sense of what is right and proper, but because it is God's will! No other reason need be assigned. Here, indeed, is the acid test of faith.
Here, too, many stumble and fall, because such walk by sight and not by faith. Only those who can truly say, "Speak, Lord; thy servant heareth; command, and he will obey," can ever get to heaven.
11 For he that said, Do not commit adultery, said also, Do not kill.---These two commandments, from the second table of the law (man's duty to man), are cited to show that the law is one, because it originated from one source. Inasmuch as the whole of it came from the same God, what ever portion one violates is transgression of the will of the one God. It is, therefore, absurd to assume that one portion of the law, issuing from such a lawgiver, is valid and vital, whereas, another from the same divine source, may be disregarded with impunity. The law of Jehovah is one; it is the single expression of the divine will. It must be regarded as a -unit, and respected on this basis.
The order in which these commandments appear is not significant; here the seventh comes before the sixth (the arrangement in which they originally appear in the decalogue), but the order followed here is that of the Greek Version of the Old Testament. Jesus cited them in this order in Luke 18:20, as did Paul in Romans 13:9.
now if thou dost not commit adultery, but killest, thou art become a transgressor of the law.---The meaning is, Though you meticulously observe the first of these commandments, but disregard and disobey the second, you are a transgressor of the law, because the law which forbids adultery, also forbids the unlawful taking of human life. It is all the same law; and, it originated with the same lawgiver. It is no defense against the charge of drunkenness, that one is not a thief, not a murderer, not an embezzler, etc.; the law which forbids these, forbade that, also. In the final analysis, law exists as a disciplinary measure for the good of man. In an important sense, all commandments are, in principle, included in each one, inasmuch as each is a expression of the authority of the lawgiver; and, to violate one puts the violator in conflict with the will of him who originated all of them.
It would be an extension of the principle here taught beyond that intended and beyond that which is right to assume from this that one is as guilty who violates but one precept of Jehovah, as one who has violated a thousand such precepts; or, that there is but one plateau of depravity, and that one reaches it on the occasion of the first sin. Such is not taught, in any sense, here. What is taught is that any sin, however insignificant it may appear to the sinner, or to those about him, is as much a violation of God's will, (which is an expression of his authority and sovereignty), as any other would be. It is obvious that James has under consideration here presumptuous actions engaged in by individuals who have passed judgment on God's laws, and who have decided some of them are important, and others not. These considerations could not apply to good people who are sincerely desirous of doing all of the will of God, ancl who seek daily to do exactly this, but who through weakness, inadvertance, and ignorance unwittingly transgress his will. For these, provision has been made through the continuous cleansing of the blood of Christ to those who luep on walking in the light. (1 John 1:7-9; 1 John 2:1-4.) The writer has under contemplation here those who keep the law in those instances in which they approve of what God has said, and who hesitate not to violate it in those instances in which they disapprove, or which they regard as of little consequence.
David said, "Blessed is the man that feareth Jehovah, that delighteth greatly in his commandments." (Psalms 112:1.) ·'I have rejoiced in the way of thy testimonies, as much as in all riches. I will meditate on thy precepts, and have respect unto thy ways. I will delight myself in thy statutes : I will not forget thy word." (Psalms 119:14-16.) May we ever seek to imitate the Psalmist in this respect.
12 So speak ye and so do, as men that are to be judged by a law of liberty.---- The verbs "speak," and "do," are present active imperatives, and thus designate habitual activity. "Ever speak and ever do as men that are to be judged ..... " There is a day of judgment coming. (Daniel 12:2; Romans 14:12; 2 Corinthians 5 :I0.) It is, therefore, vitally important that we should keep on ~peaking and keep on doing in a fashion dictated by the realization that one day we must give an account for our speaking and our doing before the Judge of all the earth. To speall and to do, sums up all that we do and all that we say. Here, as often elsewhere in the Epistle, the writer emphasizes the importance of proper speaking and doing; and, thus repeats the principles which the Lord himself taught: "And I say unto you, that every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account thereof in the day of judgment. For by thy words thou shalt be justified, and hy thy words thou shalt be condemned." (Matthew 12:36-37.)
That by which all men are to be judged is "a law of liberty." It is, therefore (a) law (a rule of action); (b) a law of liberty, in that it leads to liberty for those formerly enslaved by sin. For the significance of the word law, see comments on James 1:25. The "law of liberty" is the same as the gospel, "the implanted word" (James 1:21), and the "word of good tidings'' ( l Pet. 1: 25). Those who humbly submit their wills to Christ, and who become obedient to the principles contained in the law of God, do not enslave themselves; on the contrary, they come into possession of true liberty, obtainable in no other way. This liberty is not license; the ideas are mutually exclusive; the liberty thus enjoyed necessitates restraints without which man could not survive in a state of society, nor be happy. "For ye, brethren, were called for freedom; only use not your freedom for an occasion to the flesh, but through love, be servants one to another. For the whole law is fulfilled in one word, even in this: Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.
But if ye bite and devour one another, take heed that ye be not consumed one of another." (Galatians 5:13-14.) By the law of liberty we are to live, and by it we are to be judged. Fortunate indeed are we that it is not the law of Moses, since none can keep it perfectly today (Acts 15:10) ; and, since any violation thereof puts us under the condemnation of the whole. 'We may indeed rejoice that in Christ we have been delivered from the law of Moses and are privileged to approach God through the great sacrifice which he made in our behalf. "There is therefore now no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus. For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus made me free from the law of sin and death .... " (Romans 8:1-2.)
13 For judgment is without mercy to him that hath showed no mercy:---There will be mercy shown in judgment for those who have faithfully served the Lord, and whose lapses were unintentional and absolved in the blood of Christ; but, those who have shown others no mercy need not expect mercy themselves when before the judgment seat of Christ they come to stand. (Acts 17:30; 1 Corinthians 5:10.) The word translated "mercy." eleos, means pity for those in distress. The close connection between this statement and that appearing in James 2:2, should be observed. Instead of showing compassion on the poor, as they ought to have done, James' readers had treated them with contempt, and had turned their attention to the rich simply because they were rich. They had shown no pity for the poor; if they persisted in this course, no pity would be shown for them in the judgment! It is remarkable that our Lord, in his description of the Judgment, affirmed precisely this same principle: "Then shall he say also unto them on the left hand, Depart from me, ye cursed, into the eternal fire which is prepared for the devil and his angels; for I was hungry, and ye did not give me to eat; I was thirsty, and ye gave me no drink; I was a stranger, and ye took me not in ; naked, and ye clothed me not; sick, and in prison, and ye visited me not. Then shall they also answer, saying, Lord, when saw we thee hungry, or athirst, or a stranger, or naked, or sick, or in prison, and did not minister unto thee?
Then shall he answer them, saying, Verily I say unto you, Inasmuch as ye did it not unto one of these least, ye did it not unto me." (Matthew 25:41-45.) It is the merciful who shall obtain mercy (Matthew 5:7) ; those who have been merciless need not expect it when they need it most. To be forgiven, we must forgive others; to avoid condemnation, we must not exercise adverse judgment toward others. (Matthew 6:15; Matthew 7:1.) The debtor, forgiven of his great and hopeless debt, need not expect God, at the last day, to lift his own tremendous obligation, if he will not mark off an insignificant debt (of sin) owed him by one of his brothers. (Matthew 18:23-25.) This principle the text teaches with great clarity. Indeed, the Greek'. is even more emphatic than the English translation, signifying, "For the judgment shall be merciless to him that worked no mercy." Here, again, there is obvious reference to our Lord's teaching in the mountain instruction (Matthew 5, 6, 7), to which James so often reverts.
mercy glorieth against judgment.--- For "glorieth," some translations have "rejoiceth," "triumphs," "exults over," and the like, all of which point to the fact that where mercy can express itself, it always transcends judgment. Mercy cancels out judgment (condemnation) ; those who have been merciful, may properly exult in the mercy which they shall receive at the judgment. None of us can hope to stand before God on our own merit; we all are in need of the divine mercy. But, to enjoy it ourselves, we must show it to others. Mercilessness in us toward others, whether rich or poor, will effectively close the door of mercy to us when we need it most. Let us, at this moment, memorize the following words, and make them a part of our daily devotions: "Blessed are the merciful: for they shall obtain mercy." (Matthew 5:7.)