Canon IX.
If any Clergyman have a matter against another clergyman, he shall not forsake his
bishop and run to secular courts; but let him first lay open the matter before his own Bishop,
or let the matter be submitted to any person whom each of the parties may, with the Bishop’s
consent, select. And if any one shall contravene these decrees, let him be subjected to ca-
nonical penalties. And if a clergyman have a complaint against his own or any other bishop,
let it be decided by the synod of the province. And if a bishop or clergyman should have a
difference with the metropolitan of the province, let him have recourse to the Exarch of the
Diocese, or to the throne of the Imperial City of Constantinople, and there let it be tried.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon IX.
Litigious clerics shall be punished according to canon, if they despise the episcopal and
resort to the secular tribunal. When a cleric has a contention with a bishop let him wait till
the synod sits, and if a bishop have a contention with his metropolitan let him carry the case
to Constantinople.
Johnson.
Let the reader observe that here is a greater privilege given by a General Council to the
see of Constantinople than ever was given by any council, even that of Sardica, to the bishop
of Rome, viz., that any bishop or clergyman might at the first instance bring his cause before
the bishop of Constantinople if the defendant were a metropolitan.
Hefele.
That our canon would refer not merely the ecclesiastical, but the civil differences of the
clergy, in the first case, to the bishop, is beyond a doubt. And it comes out as clearly from
the word πρότερον (= at first) that it does not absolutely exclude a reference to the secular
judges, but regards it as allowable only when the first attempt at an adjustment of the con-
troversy by the bishop has miscarried. This was quite clearly recognized by Justinian in his
123d Novel, c. 21: “If any one has a case against a cleric, or a monk, or a deaconess, or a
nun, or an ascetic, he shall first make application to the bishop of his opponent, and he shall
decide. If both parties are satisfied with his decision, it shall then be carried into effect by
the imperial judge of the locality. If, however, one of the contending parties lodges an appeal
against the bishop’s judgment within ten days, then the imperial judge of the locality shall
decide the matter. There is no doubt that the expression “Exarch” employed in our canon,
and also in canon 17, means, in the first place, those superior metropolitans who have sev-
eral ecclesiastical provinces under them. Whether, however, the great patriarchs, properly
so called, are to be included under it, may be doubted. The Emperor Justinian, in c. 22 of
his Novel just quoted (l. c.) in our text has, without further explanation, substituted the ex-
pression Patriarch for Exarch, and in the same way the commentator Aristenus has declared
both terms to be identical, adding that only the Patriarch of Constantinople has the privilege
Canon IX.
506
Canon IX.