Son—words, which, as he himself says, are wont to perish as soon as they are uttered? No
one, methinks, who has common sense will accept this as the truth, especially as all sound
is poured forth into the air. For voice cannot be produced unless it takes consistence in air.
Now, even they themselves must suppose some medium of communication between the
speaker and him to whom he speaks. For if there were no such medium, how could the voice
travel from the speaker to the hearer? What, then, will they say is the medium or interval
by which they divide the Father from the Son? Between bodies, indeed, there is an interval
of atmospheric space, differing in its nature from the nature of human bodies. But God,
Who is intangible, and without form, and pure from all composition, in communicating
His counsels with the Only-Begotten Son, Who is similarly, or rather in the same manner,
immaterial and without body—if He made His communication by voice, what medium
would He have had through which the word, transmitted as in a current, might reach the
ears of the Only-Begotten? For we need hardly stop to consider that God is not separable
into apprehensive faculties, as we are, whose perceptions separately apprehend their corres-
ponding objects; e.g. sight apprehends what may be seen, hearing what may be heard, so
that touch does not taste, and hearing has no perception of odours and flavours, but each
confines itself to that function to which it was appointed by nature, holding itself insensible,
as it were, to those with which it has no natural correspondence, and incapable of tasting
the pleasure enjoyed by its neighbour sense. But with God it is otherwise. All in all, He is at
once sight, and hearing, and knowledge; and there we stop, for it is not permitted us to
ascribe the more animal perceptions to that refined nature. Still we take a very low view of
God, and drag down the Divine to our own grovelling standard, if we suppose the Father
speaking with His mouth, and the Son’s ear listening to His words. What, then, are we to
suppose is the medium which conveys the Father’s voice to the hearing of the Son? It must
be created or uncreate. But we may not call it created; for the Word was before the creation
of the world: and beside the Divine nature there is nothing uncreate. If, therefore, there was
no creation then, and the Word spoken of in the cosmogony was older than creation, will
he, who maintains that speech and a voice are meant by “the Word,” suggest what medium
existed between the Father and the Son, whereby those words and sounds were expressed?
For if a medium exist, it must needs exist in a nature of its own, so as to differ in nature both
from the Father and the Son. Being, then, something of necessity different, it divides the
Father and the Son from each other, as though inserted between the two. What, then, could
it be? Not created, for creation is younger than the Word. Generated we have learnt the
Only-begotten (and Him alone) to be. Except the Father, none is ungenerate. Truth, therefore,
obliges us to the conclusion that there is no medium between the Father and the Son. But
where separation is not conceived of the closest connection is naturally implied. And what
513
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.