all considered in the light of their own council of Bagai and its sequences. [Cp. Retractt. II.
xxvi.].
After concluding his work against Cresconius, he issued, probably in this same year, a
little treatise he had promised, containing a collection of proofs both for Donatist and
Catholic popular use. To the pledge itself an unknown Donatist replied, which led to the
production of a second book, whose title Augustin designed to be: Contra nescio quem
Donatistam. The original promise was fulfilled in the publication of the Probationes et
Testimonia contra Donatistas, embracing all the ecclesiastical and public acts and Scripture
proofs bearing on the questions between them. It was designed mainly for public reading
in the basilicas. Both were joined in one book, although apparently afterwards separated.
In each he confesses to the error of placing the purgation of Felix after instead of before the
vindication of Cæcilian. At this writing he still regarded the Donatists as psychics and babes,
but in his old age corrects his application of the words to them, since he came to consider
them rather as dead and lost. Unfortunately neither treatise has been preserved. [Cp. Re-
tractt. II. xxvii. and xxviii.].
He also conceived the plan of preparing a polemic for the people who had little time
for extended reading, by refuting the entire theory of the schism through the story of the
excision and restoration of the Maximianists. It appeared c. 406 A.D. under the name of
Admonitio Donatistarum de Maximianistis: this too is lost. [Cp. Retractt. II. xxix.].
An acquaintance of earlier days in Carthage, Vincentius, had become bishop of the little
Rogatist fragment as the immediate successor of Rogatus himself at Cartenna. He, or some
one of that little band, had written a letter to Augustin with a pretty strong plea against
persecution. This was not unlikely in c. 408 A.D., and Augustin answers in one of his most
weighty epistles (Ep. xciii.), under the supposition that Vincentius was the author, and vin-
dicates the help of the State. Evidently a change had come over Numidia, for he boasts of
the multitudes who had been converted, and rejoices in the fruitful use of the secular arm
for their salvation. Even Circumcelliones had become steadfast Catholics. Coercion stimu-
lates the thoughtless and those bound by custom, and delivers these held back by fear; it is
like a wholesome medicine, or the wounds inflicted by a friend. God chastens in order to
388
better the life and to bring men to repentance. The householder instructs us to compel them
to come in. Sarah and Hagar are types; so the mother Church corrects her children.
Everything depends on the aim in persecution, whether it be done for oppression or for
good; it is the difference between Pharaoh and Moses in their treatment of Israel. The
Father gave up the Son, and the Son gave Himself up; while Judas betrayed Him. The
righteousness of the end for which one suffers alone constitutes martyrdom. The Rogatist
is not suffering for righteousness but for unrighteousness. Augustin is constrained to confess
that there are no persecutions recorded in the New Testament as inflicted by Christians,
but explains the omission as due to the fact that rulers were not yet members of the Church.
667
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.