In the encyclical before us he begins (1–3)
by contrasting the synod of Nicæa with that of Ariminum, and
pointing out the real history of the latter, going over again to some
extent the ground of the earlier sections of the de Synodis. He
touches (3. end) on the disastrous termination of the Council. He then
proceeds to vindicate the Nicene creed (4–8) as essentially
Scriptural, i.e. as the only possible bar to the unscriptural
formulæ of the Arians. This he illustrates (5, 6) by an account,
substantially identical with that in the de Decretis, of the
evasions of every other test by the Asian bishops at Nicæa. He
repeatedly urges that the formula was no invention of the Nicene
Fathers (6, 9), appealing to the admission of Eusebius to this effect.
He attacks the Homœan position, shewing that its characteristic
watchword merely dissembles the alternative between Anomœanism and
the true co-essentiality of the Son (7). The most novel argument in the
Letter is that of §4, where he refutes the repudiation of οὐσία and ὑπόστασις in the
creed of Niké by an argument from Scripture, starting from Ex. iii. 14 (as de Decr. 22 and de
Syn. 29), and turning upon the equivalence of the two terms in
question. This would appeal to Westerns, and expresses the usual view
of Ath. himself (Tom. ad Ant. Introd.) but would not have much
force with those who were accustomed to the Eastern terminology.