It is
from expressions such as this that the Greek Fathers have been accused
of tritheism. The truth is, every illustration, as being incomplete on
one or other side of it, taken by itself, tends to heresy. The title
Son by itself suggests a second God, as the title Word a mere
attribute, and the title Instrument a creature. All heresies are
partial views of the truth, and are wrong, not so much in what they
say, as in what they deny. The truth, on the other hand, is a positive
and comprehensive doctrine, and in consequence necessarily mysterious
and open to misconception. vid. de Syn. 41, note 1. When Athan,
implies that the Eternal Father is in the Son, though remaining what He
is, as a man in his child, he is intent only upon the point of the
Son’s connaturality and equality, which the Arians denied. Cf.
Orat. iii. §5; Ps.-Ath. Dial. i. (Migne xxviii. 1144
C.). S. Cyril even seems to deny that each individual man may be
considered a separate substance except as the Three Persons are such
(Dial. i. p. 409); and S. Gregory Nyssen is led to say that,
strictly speaking, the abstract man, which is predicated of
separate individuals, is still one, and this with a view of
illustrating the Divine Unity. ad Ablab. t. 2. p. 449. vid.
Petav. de Trin. iv. 9.