state in which it has been eternally, then at least its deliverance from misery is something
new, since, by their own showing, the misery from which it is delivered is itself, too, a new
experience. And if this new experience fell out by accident, and was not embraced in the
order of things appointed by Divine Providence, then where are those determinate and
measured cycles in which no new thing happens, but all things are reproduced as they were
before? If, however, this new experience was embraced in that providential order of nature
(whether the soul was exposed to the evil of this world for the sake of discipline, or fell into
it by sin), then it is possible for new things to happen which never happened before, and
which yet are not extraneous to the order of nature. And if the soul is able by its own im-
prudence to create for itself a new misery, which was not unforeseen by the Divine Provid-
ence, but was provided for in the order of nature along with the deliverance from it, how
can we, even with all the rashness of human vanity, presume to deny that God can create
new things—new to the world, but not to Him—which He never before created, but yet
foresaw from all eternity? If they say that it is indeed true that ransomed souls return no
more to misery, but that even so no new thing happens, since there always have been, now
are, and ever shall be a succession of ransomed souls, they must at least grant that in this
case there are new souls to whom the misery and the deliverance from it are new. For if
they maintain that those souls out of which new men are daily being made (from whose
bodies, if they have lived wisely, they are so delivered that they never return to misery) are
not new, but have existed from eternity, they must logically admit that they are infinite.
For however great a finite number of souls there were, that would not have sufficed to make
perpetually new men from eternity,—men whose souls were to be eternally freed from this
mortal state, and never afterwards to return to it. And our philosophers will find it hard to
explain how there is an infinite number of souls in an order of nature which they require
shall be finite, that it may be known by God.
And now that we have exploded these cycles which were supposed to bring back the
soul at fixed periods to the same miseries, what can seem more in accordance with godly
reason than to believe that it is possible for God both to create new things never before
241
created, and in doing so, to preserve His will unaltered? But whether the number of
eternally redeemed souls can be continually increased or not, let the philosophers themselves
decide, who are so subtle in determining where infinity cannot be admitted. For our own
part, our reasoning holds in either case. For if the number of souls can be indefinitely in-
creased, what reason is there to deny that what had never before been created, could be
created? since the number of ransomed souls never existed before, and has yet not only been
once made, but will never cease to be anew coming into being. If, on the other hand, it be
more suitable that the number of eternally ransomed souls be definite, and that this number
will never be increased, yet this number, whatever it be, did assuredly never exist before,
and it cannot increase, and reach the amount it signifies, without having some beginning;
548
Of the Impiety of Those Who Assert that the Souls Which Enjoy True and Perfect…