VER.24— 34. ST.JOHN. 337
Me of sin? ALCUIN. The man, thathe might neitherex
pose himselftocalumny,nor at the same time concealthe
truth,answersnot thathe knew Him tobe righteous,but,
Whether He be a sinneror no,I know not. CHRYS. But Chrys.
how comes this,whetherHe be a sinner,I know not,from ^°™'2
one who had said,He is a Prophet? Did the blindfear?
farfrom it: he onlythoughtthatour Lord'sdefencelayin
the witnessof the fact,more than in another'spleading.
And he givesweightto his replyby the mention of the
benefithe had received: One thingI know, that,whereas
I was blind,now I see:as ifto say,I say nothingas to
whetherHe isa sinner; but only repeatwhat I know for
certain.So beingunabletooverturnthe factitselfof the
miracle,theyfallback upon formerarguments,and enquire
the manner of the cure: justas dogs in huntingpursue
whereverthescenttakesthem : Then saidtheytohim again,
What did He do to thee? How openedHe thineeyes? i.e.
was itby any charm ? For they do not say,How didst
thousee? but,How openedHe thineeyes? to givethe man
an opportunityof detractingfrom the operation.So long
now asthematterwantedexamining,theblindman answers
gentlyand quietly; but,thevictorybeinggained,he grows
bolder; He answeredthem,I have toldyou already,and ye
did not hear: whereforewould ye hearitagain? i.e.Ye do
not attendtowhat is said,and thereforeI willno longer
answeryou vainquestions,put forthe sakeof cavil,notto
gainknowledge: Willye alsobeHis disciples? AUG. WillAug.Tr.ye also?i.e.I am already,do ye wish to be? I see now,xliv.••u-
but do not envy. He saysthisin indignationat theob
stinacyoftheJews; nottoleratingblindness,now thathe isvideonon
no longerblindhimself.CHRYS. As thentruthisstrength,invidco.
so falsehoodisweakness: truthelevatesand ennobleswhom- H"£
everittakesup, however mean before: falsehoodbringsiviii.2.
eventhestrongto weaknessand contempt.
Then theyreviledhim and said,Thou art His disciple.
AUG. A maledictiononlyin the intentionof the speakers,Aug.Tr.
not in the words themselves.May such a maledictionbe sA<«W-
upon us,and upon our children! It follows: But we areMoses'disciples.We know thatGod spakeuntoMoses. But •
ye shouldhave known, thatour Lord was prophesiedof by
VOL.iv. z