Cardinal Noris, in his Dissertatio Historica de
Synodo Quinta, is of opinion that Origen was twice condemned by the
Fifth Synod; the first time by himself before the eight sessions of
which alone the acts remain, and again after those eight sessions, in
connexion with two of his chief followers, Didymus the Blind and the
deacon Evagrius. The Jesuit, John Garnier wrote in opposition to
Noris; but his work, while exceedingly clever, is considered by the
learned to contain (as Hefele says) “many statements [which] are
rash, arbitrary, and inaccurate, and on the whole it is seen to be
written in a spirit of opposition to Noris.” Hefele.
Hist. Councils, Vol. IV., p. 230, note. In defence of Noris’s main
contention came forward the learned Ballerini brothers, of
Verona. In their Defensio dissertationis Norisianæ de
Syn. V. adv. diss. P. Garnerii, they expand and amend Noris’s
hypothesis. But after all is said the matter remains involved in
the greatest obscurity, and it is far easier to bring forward
objections to the arguments in defence of either view than to bring
forward a theory which will satisfy all the conditions of the
problem.