90
objects sought after in a certain order and sequence of time—if I say we could reason like
that in the case of the Almighty, so that we could say He possessed His Ungeneracy at one
time, and after that acquired His power, and then His imperishability, and then His Wisdom,
and advancing so became Father, and after that Just and then Everlasting, and so came into
all that enters into the philosophical conception of Him, in a certain sequence—then it
would not be so manifestly absurd to think that one of His names has precedence of another
name, and to talk of His being first Ungenerate, and after that having become Father.
As it is, however, no one is so earth-bound in imagination, so uninitiated in the sublim-
ities of our Faith, as to fail, when once he has apprehended the Cause of the universe, to
embrace in one collective and compact whole all the attributes which piety can give to God;
and to conceive instead of a primal and a later attribute, and of another in between, super-
vening in a certain sequence. It is not possible, in fact, to traverse in thought one amongst
those attributes and then reach another, be it a reality or a conception, which is to transcend
the first in antiquity. Every name of God, every sublime conception of Him, every utterance
or idea that harmonizes with our general ideas with regard to Him, is linked in closest union
with its fellow; all such conceptions are massed together in our understanding into one
collective and compact whole namely, His Fatherhood, and Ungeneracy, and Power, and
Imperishability, and Goodness, and Authority, and everything else. You cannot take one
of these and separate it in thought from the rest by any interval of time, as if it preceded or
followed something else; no sublime or adorable attribute in Him can be discovered, which
is not simultaneously expressed in His everlastingness. Just, then, as we cannot say that God
was ever not good, or powerful, or imperishable, or immortal, in the same way it is a blas-
phemy not to attribute to Him Fatherhood always, and to say that that came later. He Who
is truly Father is always Father; if eternity was not included in this confession, and if a
foolishly preconceived idea curtailed and checked retrospectively our conception of the
Father, true Fatherhood could no longer be properly predicated of Him, because that pre-
conceived idea about the Son would cancel the continuity and eternity of His Fatherhood.
How could that which He is now called be thought of something which came into existence
subsequent to these other attributes? If being first Ungenerate He then became Father, and
received that name, He was not always altogether what He is now called. But that which the
God now existing is He always is; He does not become worse or better by any addition, He
does not become altered by taking something from another source. He is always identical
with Himself. If, then, He was not Father at first, He was not Father afterwards. But if He
is confessed to be Father (now), I will recur to the same argument, that, if He is so now, He
always was so; and that if He always was, He always will be. The Father therefore is always
Father; and seeing that the Son must always be thought of along with the Father (for the
title of father cannot be justified unless there is a son to make it true), all that we contemplate
in the Father is to be observed also in the Son. “All that the Father hath is the Son’s; and all
172
Several ways of controverting his quibbling syllogisms.