72
Excursus on Second Marriages, Called Digamy.
To distinguish contemporaneous from successive bigamy I shall use throughout this
volume the word “digamy” to denote the latter, and shall thus avoid much confusion which
otherwise is unavoidable.
The whole subject of second, and even of third and fourth marriages has a great interest
for the student of early ecclesiastical legislation, and I shall therefore treat the matter here
(as I shall hope) sufficiently and refer the reader for its fuller treatment to books more espe-
cially upon the subject.
The general position of the Church seems to have been to discourage all second mar-
riages, and to point to a single matrimonial connexion as the more excellent way. But at
the same time the principle that the marriage obligation is severed by death was universally
recognised, and however much such fresh marriages may have been disapproved of, such
disapproval did not rest upon any supposed adulterous character in the new connexion. I
cite a portion of an admirable article upon the subject by an English barrister of Lincoln’s
Inn.
(J. M. Ludlow, in Smith and Cheetham, Dictionary of Christian Antiquities, sub voce
Digamy.)
Although among the earlier Romans120 there was one form of marriage which was in-
dissoluble, viz., that by confarreatio, still generally a second marriage either after death or
divorce was by no means viewed with disfavour.…Meanwhile an intensifying spirit of as-
ceticism was leading many in the Church to a condemnation of second marriage in all cases.
Minucius Felix (Octavius, c. 31, § 5) only professes on behalf of the Christians a preference
for monogamy. Clement of Alexandria (a.d. 150–220) seems to confine the term marriage
to the first lawful union (Stromata, Bk. ii.).…It would seem, however, that when these views
were carried to the extent of absolute prohibition of second marriages generally by several
heretical sects, the Montanists (see Augustine, De Hæresibus, c. xxvi.), the Cathari (ib., c.
xxxviii.), and a portion at least of the Novatianists (see Cotel., Patr. Apol., vol. i., p. 91, n.
16) the Church saw the necessity of not fixing such a yoke on the necks of the laity. The
forbiddance of second marriage, or its assimilation to fornication, was treated as one of the
marks of heresy (Augustin. u. s.; and see also his De Bono Vid., c. vi.). The sentiment of
Augustine (in the last referred to passage) may be taken to express the Church’s judgment
at the close of the fourth century: “Second marriages are not to be condemned, but had in
less honour,” and see also Epiphanius, in his Exposition of the Catholic Faith.
To these remarks of Mr. Ludlow’s, I may add that St. Ambrose had written (De Viduis,
c. xi.), “We do not prohibit second marriages, but we do not approve marriages frequently
120 The reader may recall the words of Dido: Ille meos, primusqui me sibi junxit, amores Abstulit; ille habeat
secum servetque sepulcro
Excursus on Second Marriages, Called Digamy.
155
Excursus on Second Marriages, Called Digamy.