While it cannot be denied that the teaching of
Cassian and his school in denying the necessity of initial and
prevenient grace is erroneous and opens a door at which Pelagianism may
easily creep in, yet it was an honest attempt to vindicate human
responsibility; and it must be frankly admitted that the teaching of
Augustine was one-sided and required to be balanced: nor would the
question have ever been brought into prominence had it not been for the
hard and rigorous way in which the doctrine of Predestination was
taught, and the denial that the possibility of salvation lay within the
reach of all men. While, then, it is granted that a verdict of guilty
must be returned on the charge of Semi-Pelagianism in Cassian’s
case, we are surely justified in claiming that a recommendation to
mercy be attached to it on the plea of extenuating circumstances. Since
his death Cassian has ever occupied a somewhat ambiguous position in
the mind of the Church. Never formally canonized, his name is not found
in the Calendars of the West; nor is he honoured with the title of
“Saint.” He is, however, generally spoken of as “the
blessed Cassian,” holding in this respect the same position as
Theodoret, of whom Dr. Newman says that, though he “has the
responsibility of acts which have forfeited to him that œcumenical
dignity,” yet he is “not without honorary title in the
Church’s hagiology; for he has ever been known as the
‘blessed Theodoret.’” Historical
Sketches, Vol. III., p. 307. In
the East Cassian’s position is somewhat better. He is there
regarded as a saint, and may possibly be intended by the Cassian who is
commemorated on February 29. The identification is
anything but certain, for though there is no difficulty in the term
῾Ρωμαῖος, as that is also
applied to our author by Photius, yet the additional statement made in
the Horologion, that he was originally στρατιωτικὸς
τήν τάξιν, suggests
that a different person is alluded to, possibly the same as the Cassian
commemorated in the Roman martyrology on August 13.
A list of some twenty-five churches
where Cassian is honoured as a saint is given in Guesnay’s
Cassianus Illustratus. It is only natural
that this difference should be made, for the Eastern Church has always
held a milder view of the effect of the Fall than that which has been
current in the West since the days of Augustine; and, indeed, Cassian,
in making his protest against the rising tide of Augustinianism, was in
the main only handing on the teaching which he had received from his
Eastern instructors.