Chapter XIII.
The ideas of those philosophers are refuted who deny to God the care of the whole
world, or of any of its parts.
47. But let us return to our point, lest we seem to have lost sight of the break we made
in answering the ideas of those who, seeing some wicked men, rich, joyous, full of honours,
and powerful, whilst many upright men are in want and are weak,—suppose therefore that
God either cares nothing about us (which is what the Epicureans say), or that He is ignorant
of men’s actions as the wicked say—or that, if He knows all things, He is an unjust judge in
allowing the good to be in want and the wicked to have abundance. But it did not seem out
of place to make a digression to meet an idea of this kind and to contrast it with the feelings
of those very persons whom they consider happy—for they think themselves wretched. I
suppose they would believe themselves more readily than us.
48. After this digression I consider it an easy matter to refute the rest—above all the
declaration of those who think that God has no care whatever for the world. For instance,
Aristotle declares that His providence extends only to the moon. But what workman is there
who gives no care to his work? Who would forsake and abandon what he believes himself
to have produced? If it is derogatory to rule, is it not more so to have created? Though there
is no wrong involved in not creating anything, it is surely the height of cruelty not to care
for what one has created.
49. But if some deny God to be the Creator, and so count themselves amongst the beasts
and irrational creatures, what shall we say of those who condemn themselves to such indig-
nity? They themselves declare that God pervades all things, that all depend upon His power,
that His might and majesty penetrate all the elements,—lands, heaven, and seas; yet they
think it derogatory to Him to enter into man’s spirit, which is the noblest thing He has given
us, and to be there with the full knowledge of the divine Majesty.
50. But philosophers who are held to be reasonable laugh at the teacher62 of these ideas
as besotted and licentious. But what shall I say of Aristotle’s idea? He thinks that God is
satisfied with His own narrow bounds, and lives within the prescribed limits of His kingdom.
This, however, is also what the poets’ tales tell us. For they relate that the world is divided
between three gods, so that it has fallen to the lot of one to restrain and rule heaven, to an-
other the sea, and to a third the lower regions. They have also to take care not to stir up war
one with the other by allowing thoughts and cares about the belongings of others to take
hold of them. In the same way, Aristotle also declares that God has no care for the earth, as
He has none for the sea or the lower regions. How is it that these philosophers shut out of
their ranks the poets whose footsteps they follow?63
62 It is only fair to state that the character of Epicurus is mainly known in modern times from opponents or
persons who did not understand him. See the account in Dict. of Gr. and Rom. Biography.
63 Arist. Metaph. i. 2. An allusion to Aristotle’s saying that “the poets lie much.”
Chapter XIII. The ideas of those philosophers are refuted who deny to God the care of the whole world, or of any of its parts.
49
Chapter XIII. The ideas of those philosophers are refuted who deny to God…