The tract before us is in effect a fierce
anonymous pamphlet against Constantius. Even apart from the references
in the letters to the Monks and to Serapion (see below), the work bears
clear marks of having been intended for secret circulation (for the
practice, see Fialon, pp. 193–199). ‘Instead of the
“pious” Emperor who was so well versed in Scripture, whose
presence would gladden a dedication festival, whose well-known humanity
forbade the supposition that he could have perpetrated a deliberate
injustice, we find a Costyllius (or “Connikin”) whose
misdeeds could only be palliated by the imbecility which rendered him
the slave of his own servant—inhuman towards his nearest of
kin,—false and crafty, a Pharaoh, a Saul, an Ahab, a Belshazzar,
more cruel than Pilate or Maximian, ignorant of the Gospels, a patron
of heresy, a precursor of Antichrist, an enemy of Christ, as if
himself, Antichrist, and—the words must be
written—self-abandoned to the future doom of fire’ (Bright,
Introd. p. lxxviii., and see §§9, 30, 32, 34, 40, 45,
46, 51, 53, 67–70, 74, 80). There are certainly many passages
which one could wish that Athanasius had not written,—one, not
necessary to specify, in which he fully condescends to the coarse
brutality of the age, mingling it unpardonably with holy things. But
Athanasius was human, and exasperated by inhuman vindictiveness and
perfidy. If in the passages referred to he falls below himself, and
speaks in the spirit of his generation, there are not wanting passages
equal in nobility to anything he ever wrote. Once more to quote Dr.
Bright: ‘The beautiful description of the Archbishop’s
return from his second exile, and of its moral and religious effect
upon Alexandrian Church society (25), the repeated protests against the
principle of persecution as alien to the mind of the Church of Christ
(29, 33, 67), the tender allusion to sympathy for the poor as
instinctive in human nature (63), the vivid picture—doubtless
somewhat coloured by imagination—of the stand made by Western
bishops, and notably for a time by Liberius, against the tyrannous
dictation of Constantius in matters ecclesiastical (34 sqq. 76),
the generous estimate of Hosius and Liberius in the hour of their
infirmity (41, 45), the three golden passages which describe the union
maintained by a common faith and a sincere affection between friends
who are separated from each other (40), the all-sufficient presence of
God with His servants in their extremest solitude (47), and the future
joy when heaven would be to sufferers for the truth as a calm haven to
sailors after a storm (79). It is in such contexts that we see the true
Athanasius, and touch the source of his magnificent insuperable
constancy’ (p. lxxix.). Nothing could be more just, or more
happily put. It ought to be noted before leaving this part of the
subject, that the language put into the mouth of Constantius and the
Arians (33 fin. 1, 3, 9, 12, 15, 30, 42, 45, 60), is not so much a
report of their words as ‘a representationad invidiam of
what is assumed to have been in their minds.’ Other instances of
this are to be found in Athanasius (Ep. Æg. 18,
Orat. iii. 17), and he uses the device advisedly (de Syn.
7, middle).