they best could; while the bishop hid himself in some crevice into which he forced himself
with difficulty, and in which he lay folded double while he heard the voices of the ruffians
seeking him to kill him, and expressing their mortification that through his escaping them
their principal design in this grievous outrage had been frustrated. These things went on
from about the tenth hour until the night was far advanced. No attempt at resistance or
rescue was made by those whose authority might have had influence on the mob. The only
one who interfered was a stranger, through whose exertions a number of the servants of
God were delivered from the hands of those who were trying to kill them, and a great deal
of property was recovered from the plunderers by force: whereby it was shown how easily
these riotous proceedings might have been either prevented wholly or arrested, if the citizens,
and especially the leading men, had forbidden them, either from the first or after they had
begun.
9. Accordingly you cannot in that community draw a distinction between innocent and
guilty persons, for all are guilty; but perhaps you may distinguish degrees of guilt. Those
are in a comparatively small fault, who, being kept back by fear, especially by fear of offending
those whom they knew to have leading influence in the community and to be hostile to the
Church, did not dare to render assistance to the Christians; but all are guilty who consented
to these outrages, though they neither perpetrated them nor instigated others to the crime:
more guilty are those who perpetrated the wrong, and most guilty are those who instigated
them to it. Let us, however, suppose that the instigation of others to these crimes is a matter
of suspicion rather than of certain knowledge, and let us not investigate those things which
can be found out in no other way than by subjecting witnesses to torture. Let us also forgive
those who through fear thought it better for them to plead secretly with God for the bishop
and His other servants, than openly to displease the powerful enemies of the Church. What
reason can you give for holding that those who remain should be subjected to no correction
and restraint? Do you really think that a case of such cruel rage should be held up to the
world as passing unpunished? We do not desire to gratify our anger by vindictive retribution
for the past, but we are concerned to make provision in a truly merciful spirit for the future.
Now, wicked men have something in respect to which they may be punished, and that by
Christians, in a merciful way, and so as to promote their own profit and well-being. For
they have these three things: the life and health of the body, the means of supporting that
life, and the means and opportunities of living a wicked life. Let the two former remain
untouched in the possession of those who repent of their crime: this we desire, and this we
spare no pains to secure. But as to the third, upon it God will, if it please Him, inflict pun-
ishment in His great compassion, dealing with it as a decaying or diseased part, which must
be removed with the pruning-knife. If, however, He be pleased either to go beyond this, or
not to permit the punishment to go so far, the reason for this higher and doubtless more
righteous counsel remains with Him: our duty is to devote pains and use our influence ac-
840
To Nectarius