Most Roman controversialists of recent years have admitted both the fact of Pope
Honorius’s condemnation (which Baronius denies), and the monothelite (and therefore
heretical) character of his epistles, but they are of opinion that these letters were not his ex
cathedrâ utterances as Doctor Universalis, but mere expressions of the private opinion of
the Pontiff as a theologian. With this matter we have no concern in this connexion.
I shall therefore say nothing further on this point but shall simply supply the leading
proofs that Honorius was as a matter of fact condemned by the Sixth Ecumenical Council.
1. His condemnation is found in the Acts in the xiiith Session, near the beginning.
2. His two letters were ordered to be burned at the same session.
352
3. In the xvith Session the bishops exclaimed “Anathema to the heretic Sergius, to the
heretic Cyrus, to the heretic Honorius, etc.”
4. In the decree of faith published at the xviijth Session it is stated that “the originator
of all evil…found a fit tool for his will in…Honorius, Pope of Old Rome, etc.”
5. The report of the Council to the Emperor says that “Honorius, formerly bishop of
Rome” they had “punished with exclusion and anathema” because he followed the
monothelites.
6. In its letter to Pope Agatho the Council says it “has slain with anathema Honorius.”
7. The imperial decree speaks of the “unholy priests who infected the Church and falsely
governed” and mentions among them “Honorius, the Pope of Old Rome, the confirmer of
heresy who contradicted himself.” The Emperor goes on to anathematize “Honorius who
was Pope of Old Rome, who in everything agreed with them, went with them, and
strengthened the heresy.”
8. Pope Leo II. confirmed the decrees of the Council and expressly says that he too
anathematized Honorius.337
9. That Honorius was anathematized by the Sixth Council is mentioned in the Trullan
Canons (No. j.).
10. So too the Seventh Council declares its adhesion to the anathema in its decree of
faith, and in several places in the acts the same is said.
11. Honorius’s name was found in the Roman copy of the Acts. This is evident from
Anastasius’s life of Leo II. (Vita Leonis II.)
12. The Papal Oath as found in the Liber Diurnus338 taken by each new Pope from the
fifth to the eleventh century, in the form probably prescribed by Gregory II., “smites with
eternal anathema the originators of the new heresy, Sergius, etc., together with Honorius,
because he assisted the base assertion of the heretics.”
337 “Also Honorius, qui hanc apostolicam sedem non apostolicæ traditionis doctrina lustravit, sed profana
proditione immaculatam fidem subvertere conatus est, et omnes, qui in suo errore defuncti sunt.”
338 Ed. Eugène de Rozière. Paris, 1869, No. 84.
624
Excursus on the Condemnation of Pope Honorius.