§4. He then again charges Eunomius with having learnt his term ἀγεννησίαfrom the
hieroglyphic writings, and from the Egyptian mythology and idolatry, and with bringing in
Anubis, Osiris, and Isis to the creed of Christians, and shows that, considered as admitting
His sufferings of necessity and not voluntarily, the Only-begotten is entitled to no gratitude
from men: and that fire has none for its warmth, nor water for its fluidity, as they do not refer
their results to self-determining power, but to necessity of nature1059.
Let us once more notice the passage cited. “If he can show,” he says, “that the God Who
is over all, Who is the Light unapproachable, was incarnate, or could be incarnate,….then
let him say that the Light is equal to the Light.” The purport of his words is plain from the
very form of the sentence, namely, that he does not think that it was by His almighty Godhead
that the Son proved strong for such a form of loving-kindness, but that it was by being of a
nature subject to passion that He stooped to the suffering of the Cross. Well, as I pondered
and inquired how Eunomius came to stumble into such notions about the Deity, as to think
246
that on the one side the ungenerate Light was unapproachable by its contrary, and entirely
unimpaired and free from every passion and affection, but that on the other the generate
was intermediate in its nature, so as not to preserve the Divine unsullied and pure in im-
passibility, but to have an essence mixed and compounded of contraries, which at once
stretched out to partake of good, and at the same time melted away into a condition subject
to passion, since it was impossible to obtain from Scripture premises to support so absurd
a theory, the thought struck me, whether it could be that he was an admirer of the specula-
tions of the Egyptians on the subject of the Divine, and had mixed up their fancies with his
views concerning the Only-begotten. For it is reported that they say that their fantastic mode
of compounding their idols, when they adapt the forms of certain irrational animals to human
limbs, is an enigmatic symbol of that mixed nature which they call “dæmon,” and that this
is more subtle than that of men, and far surpasses our nature in power, but has the Divine
element in it not unmingled or uncompounded, but is combined with the nature of the soul
and the perceptions of the body, and is receptive of pleasure and pain, neither of which finds
place with the “ungenerate God.” For they too use this name, ascribing to the supreme God,
as they imagine Him, the attribute of ungeneracy. Thus our sage theologian seems to us to
be importing into the Christian creed an Anubis, Isis, or Osiris from the Egyptian shrines,
all but the acknowledgment of their names: but there is no difference in profanity between
him who openly makes profession of the names of idols, and him who, while holding the
belief about them in his heart, is yet chary of their names. If, then, it is impossible to get out
of Holy Scripture any support for this impiety, while their theory draws all its strength from
the riddles of the hieroglyphics, assuredly there can be no doubt what right-minded persons
ought to think of this. But that this accusation which we bring is no insulting slander, Eun-
1059 The grammar of this section of the analysis is very much confused.
He then again charges Eunomius with having learnt his term ἀγεννησία from the hieroglyphic writings, and from the Egyptian mythology and idolatry, and with bringing in Anubis, Osiris, and Isis to the creed of Christians, and shows that, considered as admitting His sufferings of necessity and not voluntarily, the Only-begotten is entitled to no gratitude from men: and that fire has none for its warmth, nor water for its fluidity, as they do not refer their results to self-determining power, but to necessity of nature.
470
He then again charges Eunomius with having learnt his term from…