After the fiasco of the Dated Creed, the
issue of the Councils was not doubtful. The details may be reserved for
another place (pp. 448, 453 sqq.), but the general result is
noteworthy. At both Councils the court party were in a minority, and in
both alike they eventually had their way. (See Bright, Hist. Tr.
lxxxiv.–xc., and Gwatkin, 170–180.) On the whole the
Seleucian synod came out of the affair more honourably than the other,
as their eventual surrender was confined to their delegates. Both
Councils began bravely. The majorities deposed their opponents and
affirmed their own faith, the Westerns that of Nicæa, the Easterns
that of the Dedication. From both Councils deputations from each rival
section went to the Emperor, who was now at Constantinople. The
deputies from the majority at Ariminum, where the meeting had begun
fully two months before the other, were not received, but detained
first at Hadrianople, then at Niké in Thrace (chosen, says Socr.
ii. 37, to impose on the world by the name), where they were induced to
sign a recension of the Dated Creed (the Creed itself had been revoked
and recast without the date and perhaps without the κατὰ πάντα
before the preliminary meeting at Sirmium broke up, p. 466) of a more
distinctly Homœan character. Armed with this document Valens
brought them back to the Council, and ‘by threats and
cajolery’ obtained the signatures of nearly all the bishops. Yet
the stalwart Phœbadius, Claudius of Picenum, the venerable African
Muzonius, father of the Council, and a few others, were undaunted. But
Valens, by adroit dissimulation and by guiding into a manageable shape
the successive anathematisms by which his orthodoxy was tested, managed
to deceive these simple-minded Westerns, and with applause and
exultation, ‘plausu quodam et tripudio’ (Jer.), amidst
which ‘Valens was lauded to the skies’ (!), the bishops
were released from their wearisome detention and suspense. But Valens
‘cum recessisset tunc gloriabatur’ (Prov. xx. 14). The Western bishops realised too late
what they had done, ‘Ingemuit totus orbis, et se Arianum esse
miratus est.’ Valens hurried with the creed and the anathemas of
Phœbadius to Constantinople, where he found the Seleucian deputies
in hot discussion at court. The Eastern bishops at Seleucia had held to
the ‘Lucianic’ creed, and contemptuously set aside not only
the Acacian alternative (p. 466), but the whole compromise of Basil and
Mark at the Sirmian conference of the preceding May. The
‘Conservatives’ and Acacians were at open war. But the
change of the seat of war to the court gave the latter the advantage,
and Valens and Acacius were determined to secure their position at any
cost. The first step was to compel the signature of the
‘semi-Arian’ deputies to the creed of Ariminum. This was
facilitated by the renewal on the part of Acacius and Valens of their
repudiation, already announced at Seleucia (p. 466), of the ᾽Ανόμοιον, (of
course with the mental reservation that the repudiation referred only
to will). Even so, tedious discussions The
discussions, reported with every appearance of substantial accuracy by
Thdt. ii. 27, may have taken place at this time, or at the council of
the succeeding month (Thdt. fails to distinguish the two meetings).
Gwatkin, p. 180, appears to be right in adopting the former
alternative, viz. that the party of Basil prudently abstained from
attending a council in which they would be overpowered: cf. Soz. iv.
24, who however contradicts himself in the next chapter, sub
fin. But the case is not quite clear., and the threats
of Constantius, with whom Basil had now lost all his influence (Thdt.
ii. 27), were needed to bring about the required compliance late at
night on New Year’s Eve, 359–360 (Soz. iv. 23). In January,
at the dedication of the Great Church of Constantine, the second step
was taken. The revised creed of Niké was reissued without the
anathemas of Ariminum. Aetius was offered by his friend Eudoxius as a
sacrifice to the Emperor’s scruples (see the account of the
previous debates in Thdt. ubi supra), much as Arius had been
sacrificed by his fellow-Lucianists at Nicæa (§2
supra: nine bishops protested, but were allowed six months to
reconsider their objection; the six months lasted two years, and then a
reconciliation with Aetius took place for a time, Philost. vii. 6).
Next a clean sweep was made of the leading semi-Arians on miscellaneous
charges (Soz. iv. 24, sq.), and Eudoxius was installed as bishop
of the New Rome in the place of Macedonius. The sacrifice of Aetius
gave the Homœans a free hand against their opponents, and was
compensated by the appointment of numerous Anomœans to vacant
sees. In particular Eunomius replaced Eleusius at Cyzicus. In the
eastern half of the Empire Homœanism was supreme, and remained so
politically for nearly twenty years. But not in the West. Before the
Council of Constantinople met, the power of the West had passed away
from Constantius. Gaul had acknowledged Julian as Augustus, and from
Gaul came the voice of defiance for the Homœan leaders and
sympathy for their deposed opponents (Hil. Frag. xi.). And even
in the East, throughout their twenty years the Homœans retained
their hold upon the Church by a dead hand. ‘The moral strength of
Christendom lay elsewhere;’ on the one hand the followers of
Eunomius were breaking loose from Eudoxius and forming a definitely
Arian sect, those of Macedonius crystallising their cruder conservatism
into the illogical creed of the ‘Pneumatomachi;’ on the
other hand the second generation of the ‘semi-Arians’ were,
under the influence of Athanasius, working their way to the Greek
Catholicism of the future, the Catholicism of the neo-Nicene school, of
Basil and the two Gregories.