AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I.
A. Your answer to what effect ? That they
are right, or wrong ?
C. What necessity compels me to set my
opinion against other men's ? A. You are bound by the rules of discussion,
and by respect for truth. Do you not know
that every assertion either affirms, or denies,
and that what is affirmed or denied ought to
be reckoned among good or bad things ?
You must, therefore, admit, and no thanks to
you, that the statement to which my question
relates is either a good thing or a bad.
C. If in particular actions we must have
the help of God, does it follow that we are
unable to make a pen, l or mend it when it is made ? Can we not fashion the letters, be
silent or speak, sit, stand, walk or run, eat
or fast, weep or laugh, and so on, without
God's assistance ? A. From my point of view it is clearly
impossible.
C. How then have we free will, and how
can we guard the grace of God towards us,
if we cannot do even these things without
God?
4. A. The bestowal of the grace of free
will is not such as to do away wilh the sup-
port of God in particular actions.
C. The help of God is not made of no
account; inasmuch as creatures are preserved
through the grace of free will once for all
given to them. For if without God, and ex-
cept He assist me in every action, I can do
nothing. He can neither with justice crown
me for my good deeds, nor punish me for my
evil ones, but in each case He will either
receive His own or will condemn the assist-
ance He gave.
A. Tell me, then, plainly, why you do away
with the grace of God. For whatever you
destroy in the parts you must of necessity
deny in the whole.
C. I do not deny grace when I assert that
I was so created by God, that by the grace of
God it was put within the power of my choice
either to do a thing or not to do it.
A. So God falls asleep over our good
actions, when once the faculty of free will has
been given ; and we need not pray to Him to
assist us in our separate actions, since it de- pends upon our own choice and will either to
do a thing if we choose, or not to do it if we do not choose.
5. C. As in the case of other creatures, the
conditions of their creation are observed ; so,
when once the power of free will was granted,
everything was left to our own choice.
A. It follows, as I said, that I ought not to
beg the assistance ef God in the details of
conduct, because I consider it was given once for all.
C. If He co-operates with me in everything
the result is no longer mine, but His Who
assists, or rather works in and with me ; and
all the more because I can do nothing with-
out Him.
A. Have you not read, pray,1 "that it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that run-
neth, but of God that showeth mercy ! " From this we understand that to will and to
run is ours, but the carrying into effect our
willing and running pertains to the mercy of
God, and is so effected that on the one hand
in willing and running free will is preserved ;
and on the other, in consummating our willing
and running, everything is left to the power
of God. Of course, I ought now to adduce
the frequent testimony of Scripture to show that in the details of conduct the saints
intreat the help of God; and in their several
actions desire to have Him for their helper
and protector. Read through the Psalter,
and all the utterances of the saints, and you
will find their actions never unaccompanied
by prayer to God. And this is a clear proof
that you either deny the grace which you
banish from the parts of life ; or if you con-
cede its presence in the parts, a concession
plainly much against your will, you must have
come over to the views of us who preserve
free will for man, but so limit it that we do
not deny the assistance of God in each action.
6. C. That is a sophistical conclusion and a
mere display of logical skill. No one can
strip me of the power of free will ; otherwise,
if God were really my helper in what I do,
the reward would not be due to me, but to
Him who wrought in me.
A. Make the most of your free will ; arm
your tongue against God, and therein prove
yourself free, if you will, to blaspheme. But
to go a step farther, there is no doubt as to
your sentiments, and the delusions of your
profession have become as clear as day.
Now, let us turn back to the starting-point of our discussion. You said just now that,
granted God's assistance, man may be sinless if he chooses. Tell me, please, for how long ?
For ever, or only for a short time?
C. Your question is unnecessary. If I say
for a short time, for ever will none the less
be implied. For whatever you allow for a
short time, you will admit may last for ever.
A. I do not quite understand your meaning.
C. Are you so senseless that you do not
recognize plain facts?
7. A. I am not ashamed of my ignorance.
1 Pumice Urere. 1 Rom. ix. 16.