§2. He also ingeniously shows from the passage of the Gospel which speaks of “Good
Master,” from the parable of the Vineyard, from Isaiah and from Paul, that there is not a
dualism in the Godhead of good and evil, as Eunomius’ ally Marcion supposes, and declares
that the Son does not refuse the title of “good” or “Existent,” or acknowledge His alienation
from the Father, but that to Him also belongs authority over all things that come into being.
Not even Marcion himself, the patron of your opinions, supports you in this. It is true
that in common with you he holds a dualism of gods, and thinks that one is different in
nature from the other, but it is the more courteous view to attribute goodness to the God
of the Gospel. You however actually separate the Only-begotten God from the nature of
good, that you may surpass even Marcion in the depravity of your doctrines. However, they
claim the Scripture on their side, and say that they are hardly treated when they are accused
for using the very words of Scripture. For they say that the Lord Himself has said, “There
is none good but one, that is, God975.” Accordingly, that misrepresentation may not prevail
against the Divine words, we will briefly examine the actual passage in the Gospel. The history
regards the rich man to whom the Lord spoke this word as young—the kind of person, I
suppose, inclined to enjoy the pleasures of this life—and attached to his possessions; for it
says that he was grieved at the advice to part with what he had, and that he did not choose
to exchange his property for life eternal. This man, when he heard that a teacher of eternal
life was in the neighbourhood, came to him in the expectation of living in perpetual luxury,
with life indefinitely extended, flattering the Lord with the title of “good,”—flattering, I
should rather say, not the Lord as we conceive Him, but as He then appeared in the form
of a servant. For his character was not such as to enable him to penetrate the outward veil
of flesh, and see through it into the inner shrine of Deity. The Lord, then, Who seeth the
hearts, discerned the motive with which the young man approached Him as a suppliant,—that
he did so, not with a soul intently fixed upon the Divine, but that it was the man whom he
besought, calling Him “Good Master,” because he hoped to learn from Him some lore by
which the approach of death might be hindered. Accordingly, with good reason did He
Who was thus besought by him answer even as He was addressed976. For as the entreaty
was not addressed to God the Word, so correspondingly the answer was delivered to the
applicant by the Humanity of Christ, thereby impressing on the youth a double lesson. For
He teaches him, by one and the same answer, both the duty of reverencing and paying
homage to the Divinity, not by flattering speeches but by his life, by keeping the command-
ments and buying life eternal at the cost of all possessions, and also the truth that humanity,
having been sunk in depravity by reason of sin, is debarred from the title of “Good”: and
for this reason He says, “Why callest Thou Me good?” suggesting in His answer by the word
975 Cf. S. Matt. xix. 17.
976 i.e.as man, and not as God.
He also ingeniously shows from the passage of the Gospel which speaks of “Good Master,” from the parable of the Vineyard, from Isaiah and from Paul, that there is not a dualism in the Godhead of good and evil, as Eunomius' ally Marcion supposes, and declares that the Son does not refuse the title of “good” or “Existent,” or acknowledge His alienation from the Father, but that to Him also belongs authority over all things that come into being.
441
He also ingeniously shows from the passage of the Gospel which speaks of…