end, as if the meanings of the two terms were identical. If, then, by reason of His being
without end He is ungenerate, and the being without end and ungenerate are convertible
terms, and he admits that the Son also is without end, by a parity of reasoning he must ne-
cessarily admit that the Son is ungenerate, if (as he has said) His being without end and His
being without beginning are identical in meaning. For just as in the ungenerate he sees that
which is without beginning, so he allows that in that which is without end also he sees that
which is without beginning. For otherwise he would not have made the terms wholly con-
vertible. But God, he says, is ungenerate by nature, and not by contrast with the ages. Well,
who is there that contends that God is not by nature all that He is said to be? For we do not
304
say that God is just, and almighty, and Father, and imperishable, by contrast with the ages,
nor by His relation to any other thing that exists. But in connection with the subject itself,
whatever He may be in His nature, we entertain every idea that is a reverent idea; so that
supposing neither ages, nor any other created thing, had been made, God would no less be
what we believe Him to be, being in no need of the ages to constitute Him what He is. “But,”
says Eunomius, “He has a Life that is not extraneous, nor composite, nor admitting of dif-
ferences; for He Himself is Life eternal by virtue of that Life itself immortal, by virtue of that
immortality imperishable.” This we are taught respecting the Only-begotten as well; nor
can any one impugn this teaching without openly opposing the declaration of S. John. For
life was not brought in from without upon the Son either (for He says, “I am the Life1198”),
nor is His Life either composite, nor does it admit difference, but by virtue of that life itself
He is immortal (for in what else but in life can we see immortality?), and by virtue of that
immortality He is imperishable. For that which is stronger than death must naturally be
incapable of corruption.
Thus far our argument goes with him. But the riddle with which he accompanies his
words we must leave to those trained in the wisdom of Prunicus1199 to interpret: for he
seems to have produced what he has said from that system. “Being incorruptible without
beginning, He is ungenerate without end, being so called absolutely, and independently of
aught beside Himself.” Now whoever has purged ears and an enlightened understanding
knows, even without my saying it, that beyond the jingle of words produced by their ex-
traordinary combination, there is no trace of sense in what he says; and if any shadow of an
idea could be found in such a din of words, it would prove to be either profane or ridiculous.
For what do you mean when you say that He is without beginning as being without end,
and without end as being without beginning? Do you think beginning identical with end,
and that the two words are employed in the same sense, just as the appellations Simon and
Peter represent one and the same subject, and on this account, in accordance with your
1198 S. John xi. 25
1199 This may mean “short-hand” i.e. something difficult to decipher. See Book I. vi. note 10.
569
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.