The Apocalypse is one of the best authenticated books of the New
Testament. It was used by Papias and others of the earliest Fathers,
and already by Justin Martyr was expressly ascribed to the apostle
John. (Compare also the epistle of the Churches of Lyons and Vienne,
Eusebius, V. 1.) Tradition, so far as we have it, is unanimous (with
the exception of the Alogi, an insignificant heretical sect of the
second century, who attributed the Apocalypse as well as the Gospel to
Cerinthus. Caius is not an exception: see below, chap. 28, note 4) in
ascribing the Apocalypse to the apostle John, until Dionysius of
Alexandria, who subjected the book to severe literary criticism (see
below, Bk. VII. chap. 25), and upon the assumption of the genuineness
of the Gospel and the first Epistle, doubted its authenticity on
account of its divergence from these writings both in spirit and in
style. He says (VII. 25, §2) that some others before him had
denied the Johannine authorship and ascribed the book to Cerinthus, but
the way in which he speaks of them shows that there cannot have been a
ruling tradition to that effect. He may have referred simply to the
Alogi, or he may have included others of whom we do not know. He
himself rejects this hypothesis, and supposes the books to have been
written by some John, not the apostle (by what John he does not
decide), and does not deny the inspiration and prophetic character of
the book. Dionysius was led to exercise criticism upon the Apocalypse
(which was as well supported by tradition as any book of the New
Testament) from dogmatic reasons. The supposed sensuous and
materialistic conceptions of the Apocalypse were offensive to the
spiritualizing tendencies of the Alexandrian school, and the
offensiveness increased with time. Although Dionysius held the work as
inspired and authoritative, yet his position would lead logically to
the exclusion of the Apocalypse from the canon, just as Hermas had been
already excluded, although Origen held it to be inspired and
authoritative in the same sense in which Dionysius held the Apocalypse
to be,—i.e. as composed by an apostle’s pupil, not by an
apostle. Apocalyptic literature did not belong properly to the New
Testament, but rather to the prophetic portion of the Old Testament;
but the number of the Old Testament prophets was already complete
(according to the Muratorian Fragment), and therefore no prophetic
writing (e.g. Hermas) could find a place there; nor, on the other hand,
could it be made a part of the New Testament, for it was not apostolic.
The same was true of the Apocalypse of Peter, and the only thing which
kept the Apocalypse of John in the canon was its supposed apostolic
authorship. It was received as a part of the New Testament not because
it was apocalyptic, but because it was apostolic, and thus the
criticism of Dionysius would lead logically to its rejection from the
canon. John’s Apocalypse is the only New Testament book cited by
Justin as γραφή (so also
by the Epistle of Vienne and Lyons, Eusebius, V. 1), and this because
of its prophetic character. It must have been (according to their
opinion) either a true prophecy (and therefore inspired by the Holy
Spirit) or a forgery. Its authenticity being accepted, the former
alternative necessarily followed, and it was placed upon a line with
the Old Testament prophets, i.e. with the γραφή. After
Dionysius’ time doubts of its authenticity became quite
widespread in the Eastern Church, and among the doubters was Eusebius,
who evidently wished to ascribe it to the mysterious presbyter John,
whose existence he supposed to be established by Papias in a passage
quoted in chap. 39, §4, below (compare the note on the passage).
Eusebius’ treatment of the book is hesitating. He evidently
himself discredited its apostolic authority, but at the same time he
realized (as a historian more keenly than Dionysius the theologian) the
great weight of external testimony to its authenticity, and therefore
he gives his readers the liberty (in the next chapter) of putting it
either with the Homologoumena or with the νόθοι. It
legitimately belonged among the Homologoumena, but
Dionysius’ attitude toward it doubtless led Eusebius to think
that it might at some time in the future be thrown out of the canon,
and of course his own objections to its contents and his doubts as to
its apostolicity caused him to contemplate such a possibility not
without pleasure (see the next chapter, note 1). In chapter 18, above,
he speaks of it as the “so-called” Apocalypse of John, but
in other places he repeats many testimonies in favor of its
authenticity (see the next note), and only in chapter 39 does he state
clearly his own opinion in the matter, which even there he does not
press as a fixed conviction. The reason for the doubts of the
book’s genuineness on the part of Eusebius and so many others lay
evidently most of all in objections to the contents of the book, which
seemed to favor chiliasm, and had been greatly abused for the
advancement of the crassest chiliastic views. Many, like Dionysius of
Alexandria were no doubt influenced also by the idea that it was
impossible that the Gospel and the Apocalypse could be the works of one
author, and they preferred to sacrifice the latter rather than the
former. The book has found objectors in almost every age of the Church,
but has continued to hold its place in the canon (its position was
never disturbed in the Western Church, and only for some two or three
centuries after Eusebius in parts of the Eastern Church) as an
authentic work of the apostle John. The Tübingen school exalted
the Apocalypse to the honorable position of one of the five genuine
monuments of the apostolic age, and from it as a basis conducted their
attacks upon the other Johannine writings. The more modern critical
school is doubtful about it as well as the rest of the Johannine
literature, and the latest theory makes the Apocalypse a Jewish
document in a Christianized form (see above, chap. 18, note 1). Compare
especially Holtzmann’s Einleitung, p. 411–413, and
Weiss’ Einleitung, p. 93.