of this dilemma proposed to others by them. Moreover, why do they contend that this gift
is to be attributed only to the eyes, and not to all the other senses of Christ? Shall God then
be a sound, that He may be perceived by the ear? and an exhalation, that He may be discerned
by the sense of smell? and a liquid of some kind, that He may be also imbibed? and a solid
body, that He may be also touched? No, they say. What then? we reply; can God be this, or
can He not? If they say He cannot, why do they derogate from the omnipotence of God? If
they say He can, but is not willing, why do they show favour to the eyes alone, and grudge
the same honour to the other senses of Christ? Do they carry their folly just as far as they
please? How much better is our course, who do not prescribe limits to their folly, but would
fain prevent them from entering into it at all!
6. Many things may be brought forward for the confutation of that madness. Meanwhile,
however, if at any time they assail your ears, read this letter to the supporters of such error,
and do not count it too great a labour to write back to me as well as you can what they say
in reply. Let me add that our hearts are purified by faith, because the vision of God is
promised to us as the reward of faith. Now, if this vision of God were to be through the
bodily eyes, in vain are the souls of saints exercised for receiving it; nay, rather, a soul which
cherishes such sentiments is not exercised in itself, but is wholly in the flesh. For where will
382
it dwell more resolutely and fixedly than in that by means of which it expects that it shall
see God? How great an evil this would be I rather leave to your own intelligence to observe,
than labour to prove by a long argument.
May your heart dwell always under the Lord’s keeping, noble and justly distinguished
lady, and daughter worthy of honour in the love of Christ! Salute from me, with the respect
due to your worth, your sons, who are along with yourself honourable, and to me dearly
beloved in the Lord.
845
To Lady Italica