230
1. Against the so-called Phrygian1569 heresy, the power which always contends for the
truth raised up a strong and invincible weapon, Apolinarius of Hierapolis, whom we have
centuries, entirely disappeared. But although it failed and passed away, Montanism had a marked influence on
the development of the Church. In the first place, it aroused a general distrust of prophecy, and the result was
that the Church soon came to the conviction that prophecy had entirely ceased. In the second place, the Church
was led to see the necessity of emphasizing the historical Christ and historical Christianity over against the
Montanistic claims of a constantly developing revelation, and thus to put great emphasis upon the Scripture
canon. In the third place, the Church had to lay increased stress upon the organization—upon its appointed
and ordained officers—over against the claims of irregular prophets who might at any time arise as organs of
the Spirit. The development of Christianity into a religion of the book and of the organization was thus greatly
advanced, and the line began to be sharply drawn between the age of the apostles, in which there had been direct
supernatural revelations, and the later age, in which such revelations had disappeared. We are, undoubtedly, to
date from this time that exalted conception of the glory of the apostolic age, and of its absolute separation from
all subsequent ages, which marks so strongly the Church of succeeding centuries, and which led men to endeavor
to gain apostolic authority for every advance in the constitution, in the customs, and in the doctrine of the
Church. There had been little of this feeling before, but now it became universal, and it explains the great
number of pseudo-apostolic works of the third and following centuries. In the fourth place, the Chiliastic ideas
of Montanism produced a reaction in the Church which caused the final rejection of all grossly physical Premil-
lenarian beliefs which up to this time had been very common. For further particulars in regard to Montanism,
see the notes on this and the following chapters. Our chief sources for a knowledge of Montanism are to be
found in the writings of Tertullian. See, also, Epiphanius, Hær. XLVIII. and XLIX., and Jerome’s Epistle to
Marcella (Migne, Ep. 41). The fragments from the anonymous anti-Montanistic writer quoted by Eusebius in
this and the following chapter, and the fragments of Apollonius’ work, quoted in chap. 18, are of the greatest
importance. It is to be regretted that Eusebius has preserved for us no fragments of the anti-Montanistic writings
of Apolinarius and Melito, who might have given us still earlier and more trustworthy accounts of the sect. It
is probable that their works were not decided enough in their opposition to Montanism to suit Eusebius, who,
therefore, chose to take his account from somewhat later, but certainly bitter enough antagonists. The works of
the Montanists themselves (except those of Tertullian) have entirely perished, but a few “Oracles,” or prophetic
utterances, of Montanus, Priscilla, and Maximilla, have been preserved by Tertullian and other writers, and are
printed by Bonwetsch, p. 197–200. The literature upon Montanism is very extensive. We may mention here C.
W. F. Walch’s Ketzerhistorie, I. p. 611–666, A. Schwegler’s Der Montanismus und die christliche Kirche des
zweiten Jahrh. (Tübingen, 1841), and especially G. N. Bonwetzsch’s Die Geschichte des Montanismus (Erlangen,
1881), which is the best work on the subject, and indispensable to the student. Compare, also, Schaff’s Ch. Hist.
II. p. 415 sq., where the literature is given with great fullness, Salmon’s article in the Dict. of Christ. Biog., and
especially Harnack’s Dogmengeschichte, I. p. 319 sq.
543
The Circumstances related of Montanus and his False Prophets.