§ 2. Doctrine of the Holy
Trinity. “The doctrinal position of S. Cyril is
admirably described, and his orthodoxy vindicated by Cardinal Newman in
the following passage of his Preface to the Lectures in the Library of
the Fathers. “There is something very remarkable and even
startling to the reader of S. Cyril, to find in a divine of his school
such a perfect agreement, for instance as regards the doctrine of the
Trinity, with those Fathers who in his age were more famous as
champions of it. Here is a writer, separated by whatsoever cause
from what, speaking historically, may be called the Athanasian School,
suspicious of its adherents, and suspected by them; yet he, when he
comes to explain himself, expresses precisely the same doctrine as that
of Athanasius or Gregory, while he merely abstains from the particular
theological term in which the latter Fathers agreeably to the Nicene
Council conveyed it. Can we have a clearer proof that the
difference of opinion between them was not one of ecclesiastical and
traditionary doctrine, but of practical judgment? that the Fathers at
Nicæa wisely considered that, under the circumstances, the word in
question was the only symbol which would secure the Church against the
insidious heresy which was assailing it, while S. Cyril, with Eusebius
of Cæsarea, Meletius and others shrank from it, at least for a
while, as if an
addition to the Creed, or a word already taken into the service of an
opposite heresy, and likely to introduce into the Church heretical
notions? Their judgment, which was erroneous, was their own;
their faith was not theirs only, but shared with them by the whole
Christian world Preface, p.
ix..”